3 ms·
In the photovoltaics market it doesn't count as something ready for production use unless it's scaled up, and intercompatible with other industry standard stuff
by walrus01 7y ago
In the photovoltaics market it doesn't count as something ready for production use unless it's scaled up, and intercompatible with other industry standard stuff.
I can take out my Visa card right now, or send a purchase order and get a pallet of twenty, 72-cell 370W panels delivered to my doorstep or loading dock. They're really nice panels made from 156mm mono Si cells.
Their specs are well known, and they confirm to standard dimensions with their aluminum frame (1.99 x 0.99 meters), so I can mount them on a dozen different vendors' aluminum rails or other mounting systems.
I don't need any special weird connectors to wire them up in various possible configurations of series and parallel.
I can buy competing 360 to 370W panels made by ten different companies.
My skepticism of the solar tiles comes from the concept that they're very labor intensive to install, available only as a proprietary solution from one vendor, I've never seen detailed schematics of them showing exactly how they mount and interconnect, etc. If you've ever seen a consumer electronics device that is glued shut at the factory and ifixit gives it a 1 out of 10 repairability score, this is the same thing.
10-15 workers and two weeks? In a normal residential roof pv install, something has gone very wrong if three workers can't get all of the mounting and panels installed and wired in one to two days.
$100,000? I really hope that's a translation error or something, or a misunderstanding on the part of the person who wrote the article. Because I could build a truly ridiculously sized ground mount pv system for $100,000.
- _ph_ 7y agoThe question isn't how the solar tiles compete against adding panels to an existing roof - the panels are not going to be beaten in this comparison. The question is, how do the tiles compare to building a roof from scratch. And then possibly adding solar panels to the roof in addition. And of course, for all the cases where people don't want (or even are not allowed) to put panels onto their roof. And, at least in Germany, most home owners wouldn't be able to put solar onto the ground for a lack of real estate.
- walrus01 7y agoAnother question where space is at a premium would be the STC W per square meter. I think these tiles might fare a lot worse than a dozen typical 72-cell 370W panels, nevermind a 22.5%+ sunpower ultra high efficiency panel.
- _ph_ 7y agoI think the solar tiles only make sense, when you are not able to install solar panels. Be it for geometry or optical reasons.
- new_realist 7y agoThey’re still worse.