4 ms·
I spent years homeless. A. Most services aimed at the homeless would be sued out of existence if they were intended for middle class clientele. They are freque
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
I spent years homeless.
A. Most services aimed at the homeless would be sued out of existence if they were intended for middle class clientele. They are frequently quite terrible.
For example: At a free meal from the Salvation Army, an older woman sitting next to me who had just gotten out of the hospital for a heart condition had all her stuff stolen for complying with their crappy policy of leaving her stuff in the unguarded designated area. It was cold and rainy that night and she had just lost all her extra clothes and bedding.
They were giving away bedding and clothes after the meal. No one walked her to the front of the line and said "Make sure she gets what she needs to make it safely through the night."
B. I'm mostly not interested in seeing more homeless services. They are mostly a "fuck you" solution.
If we actually cared about people in the US, we would have free national health care and an appropriate housing supply. We have neither, then we blame poor people as being crazies and junkies when they end up homeless.
Then we add insult to injury by giving them terrible food with long lines and similar "services" for which we expect them to be ever so grateful.
I'm wholly unimpressed with the entire thing. The system is quite broken.
- JudgeWapner 7y agoHow telling that you lambast one of the very few agencies actually doing something about the problem (for something completely out of their control nonetheless), instead of thank them for the aid they gave you. "If you nurture a starving dog and make him prosperous, he won't bite you. This is the principal difference between a dog and a man" - Mark Twain
- DoreenMichele 7y agoNah, that wasn't lambasting. This is much closer to lambasting a homeless services organization for their shitty, shitty policies: https://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/2014/11/mission-statement-helping-homeless.html https://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/2014/11/m...
- throwaway3627 7y agoMuch peace and love <3, because there's not enough humanity between people these days it seems. How a society treats its most vulnerable, "undesirable" and powerless individuals (prisoners, homeless and other minority groups) reflects the true nature of its constituents. It's truly a shame most modern people have no idea what it's like to be homeless and/or didn't learn the golden rule or empathy in their upbringing.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI run several websites either aimed at helping homeless individuals generally or that can be useful to people who are homeless. In addition to the above website (the San Diego Homeless Survival Guide), I also run: Street Life Solutions https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/ https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/ Pocket Puter https://www.pocketputer.com/ https://www.pocketputer.com/ The Genevieve Files https://genevievefiles.blogspot.com/ https://genevievefiles.blogspot.com/ Write Pay http://writepay.blogspot.com/ http://writepay.blogspot.com/ They make me very little money, but some local homeless services and the local police department give out fliers of mine that list some of my sites. At least one local individual got back into housing, probably in part because of the information on my sites. I was acquainted with him and gave him a flier personally. The police department seems to be my best ally in that regard. Unlike most homeless services,* they don't need the homeless problem to continue to exist to give their lives meaning or justify their paychecks. They would be thrilled to see the local homeless problem resolved so they could dedicate their limited resources to dealing with crime. * (The Shirky Principle and Homelessness: https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2018/07/the-shirky-principle-and-homelessness.html https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2018/07/the-shirky-...) I'm still struggling to make ends meet and I seem to be making a dent in the homeless problem. It makes me really unsympathetic to arguments from more well-heeled people about how hard it is to solve or similar excuses for continuing to do nothing.
- JudgeWapner 7y agoRunning a website is paying lip service to the problem. It's virtual help. You can't feed someone bytes. But go on thinking you're a superhero. While salvation army feeds tens of thousands per day.
- throwaway3627 7y agoThank them for treating you like dirt? Get off your high horse of self-righteousness. Until you've been homeless, maybe you shouldn't comment.
- GlennS 7y agoI appreciate that you are trying to defend people who are doing their best, but I think overall that was an unfair and uncharitable comment. In my experience, homeless people act cringeing and fearful, and often call people Sir or Ma'am. It's pretty horrible to see someone's spirit broken that way. They aren't the people who need to learn gratitude.
- throwaway3627 7y agoMost homeless services here follow the "beggars can't be choosers" egotism of not attending to people's actual needs but rather looking down their noses on them, treating homeless people like criminals or make them jump through hoops like show animals. For example, most of the doctor specialist services here have a "full" waiting list just to schedule an appointment and force people to call at a certain time in the morning for a few spots on said list, like animals jockeying to win the lottery. Oh and the amount of food and cash aid is abysmal, not enough to feed or clothe anyone. Most services demand either employment or only apply to certain groups, leaving many people to fall between the cracks. The "social workers" are arrogant, obnoxious bureaucrats who don't listen to their clients but instead hold their aid over their heads and order them around without offering any solutions, strategies, resources or actual help... just judgement and control. And it takes years to get disability status reviewed and longer to get housing. There are at least 1500 people living rough and 500 people living in vehicles in the area.
- c22 7y agoI was out of work and almost homeless (mostly extended couch-surfing) when the Affordable Care Act went into effect so I signed up for one of the subsidized low-income plans. They assigned me a primary care provider who was two cities away and told me I would have to see them in order for my care to be fully covered. Later when I needed to see a doctor I dutifully made an appointment and rode the bus one and a half hours out there only to learn that my assigned provider was a pediatrician and she didn't feel comfortable taking me on as a patient. I contacted the plan provider and they assigned me a new doctor, but when I tried to make an appointment with him it turned out he was no longer practicing medicine. Fortunately one of his colleagues was able to take me and I finally received some care. Three months later I was informed by his office that they were no longer in-network with my plan because they had had too much difficulty getting them to honor payments. I was assigned another primary care provider but thankfully I got a job not long after that and I never experienced the thrill of discovering whether the last one was a real living doctor or perhaps an inanimate can of Dr. Pepper.
- AstralStorm 7y ago
- Fellshard 7y agoReading more of your comments in this thread, and in our interaction prior; I've determined you're an extremely bitter person. I understand what you've gone through, but that does not mean you can castigate the motives of anyone who disagrees with your policy recommendations. > If we actually cared, you would agree with me. That is not how reasonable discourse and change will take place, no matter how much expertise or intellectual might you believe you have. To be clear, I agree with some of your observations and recommendations, and disagree with others. But turning disagreement into a moral factor is not going to lead to healthy conversations here or elsewhere, and will only be adversarial or pandering.
- watwut 7y agoThere is no motive in comment you responded to. It is list of complains about actions and policies.
- Fellshard 7y ago"If we actually cared about people in the US, we would have free national health care and an appropriate housing supply." That is a statement: because we do not have free national healthcare and appropriate housing supply, we do not care about people in the US. This is patently false, and ill-motivated, seeking to disparage anyone who may offer alternative diagnoses or solutions.
- JasonFruit 7y agoThis is a major problem in discourse on political and social matters, judging by what I hear in the United States. Instead of stating a position and supporting it with reasoning, we state a position and support it with, "and you're a racist/homophobe/communist/Jacobin/baby-murderer/$OTHER_MONSTER if you disagree." Nobody is convinced by verbal brickbats like these; instead, they're convinced that their opponents are impossible fanatics who can't be reasoned with. I can't imagine a series of publications like the Federalist/Antifederalist papers today, or even something as gentle as FDR's fireside chats; we don't, on the whole, have the intellectual honesty to listen to a conversation. Listen to what is considered "winning" in a political debate: it's not the reasoned defense of a position, or proposing an innovative solution to a recognized problem, but the snappy insinuation that an opponent is a closet racist and possible pedophile. (Obviously, I'm angry here, but I'm also very, very sad.) --- edit: close paren ---
- RobertRoberts 7y agoI was homeless too, and I was grateful for what you may have considered crappy meals. I even lived on the streets with my wife for a short time, and we both appreciated low quality service. It was better than what we had, which was nothing.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI was very grateful for any help we received. But some "help" is so bad it actually makes things worse. Being forced to leave all your possessions in an unsecured area to get a meal at all is an all-too-common practice. But it's not done everywhere and it's not necessary. It's like the difference between a "bandage solution" and a "bandage" that isn't sterile. The second actively makes you worse off.
- RobertRoberts 7y agoI won't argue that some people have bad experiences but unless the workers stole the stuff then the help wasn't bad itself. Also there may be reasons for those rules that maybe you don't understand. I had to choose between hunger and safety before and you make that choice and live with it. Blaming others for trying to help you is not useful.