6 ms·
> My uncharitable take is that a lot of people in power don't care, have no heart and can't be arsed to pretend to care. Well, as someone who disagrees, but al
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
> My uncharitable take is that a lot of people in power don't care, have no heart and can't be arsed to pretend to care.
Well, as someone who disagrees, but also likes to think I have a heart, I'll give my 2c. Why don't we consider locks on your doors "hostile architecture"? Social problems are complex and difficult to solve, and just because we haven't solved them doesn't mean, for example, that people should be discouraged from trying to prevent people from urinating on their property. I mean, take one of the examples from the wikipedia article: Just because some people have a drug problem doesn't mean blue lights in a public bathroom to prevent IV drug use there is a bad thing.
Take homelessness. It is no coincidence that the cities that actually provide the most support and resources for the homeless actually have the worst homeless problems. With the lack of a national policy to deal with homelessness, providing better services does make your city a magnet for the homeless population (this is NOT an argument against providing those services, just a simple observation of cause and effect).[1] The fact that it would be good to be able to sit at a city bus stop I think is a good thing even if there are still homeless people in your city.
[1] https://cbsaustin.com/news/local/homeless-buy-one-way-bus-tickets-to-austin https://cbsaustin.com/news/local/homeless-buy-one-way-bus-ti...
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI spent years homeless. A. Most services aimed at the homeless would be sued out of existence if they were intended for middle class clientele. They are frequently quite terrible. For example: At a free meal from the Salvation Army, an older woman sitting next to me who had just gotten out of the hospital for a heart condition had all her stuff stolen for complying with their crappy policy of leaving her stuff in the unguarded designated area. It was cold and rainy that night and she had just lost all her extra clothes and bedding. They were giving away bedding and clothes after the meal. No one walked her to the front of the line and said "Make sure she gets what she needs to make it safely through the night." B. I'm mostly not interested in seeing more homeless services. They are mostly a "fuck you" solution. If we actually cared about people in the US, we would have free national health care and an appropriate housing supply. We have neither, then we blame poor people as being crazies and junkies when they end up homeless. Then we add insult to injury by giving them terrible food with long lines and similar "services" for which we expect them to be ever so grateful. I'm wholly unimpressed with the entire thing. The system is quite broken.
- JudgeWapner 7y agoHow telling that you lambast one of the very few agencies actually doing something about the problem (for something completely out of their control nonetheless), instead of thank them for the aid they gave you. "If you nurture a starving dog and make him prosperous, he won't bite you. This is the principal difference between a dog and a man" - Mark Twain
- DoreenMichele 7y agoNah, that wasn't lambasting. This is much closer to lambasting a homeless services organization for their shitty, shitty policies: https://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/2014/11/mission-statement-helping-homeless.html https://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/2014/11/m...
- throwaway3627 7y agoMuch peace and love <3, because there's not enough humanity between people these days it seems. How a society treats its most vulnerable, "undesirable" and powerless individuals (prisoners, homeless and other minority groups) reflects the true nature of its constituents. It's truly a shame most modern people have no idea what it's like to be homeless and/or didn't learn the golden rule or empathy in their upbringing.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI run several websites either aimed at helping homeless individuals generally or that can be useful to people who are homeless. In addition to the above website (the San Diego Homeless Survival Guide), I also run: Street Life Solutions https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/ https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/ Pocket Puter https://www.pocketputer.com/ https://www.pocketputer.com/ The Genevieve Files https://genevievefiles.blogspot.com/ https://genevievefiles.blogspot.com/ Write Pay http://writepay.blogspot.com/ http://writepay.blogspot.com/ They make me very little money, but some local homeless services and the local police department give out fliers of mine that list some of my sites. At least one local individual got back into housing, probably in part because of the information on my sites. I was acquainted with him and gave him a flier personally. The police department seems to be my best ally in that regard. Unlike most homeless services,* they don't need the homeless problem to continue to exist to give their lives meaning or justify their paychecks. They would be thrilled to see the local homeless problem resolved so they could dedicate their limited resources to dealing with crime. * (The Shirky Principle and Homelessness: https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2018/07/the-shirky-principle-and-homelessness.html https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2018/07/the-shirky-...) I'm still struggling to make ends meet and I seem to be making a dent in the homeless problem. It makes me really unsympathetic to arguments from more well-heeled people about how hard it is to solve or similar excuses for continuing to do nothing.
- tedivm 7y agoMost of the busing programs actually require that the person have someone to stay with on the other end of the trip. That isn't to say there isn't some abuse, but generally speaking busing actually helps get people off the street. Only 46% of homeless people are in urban areas, and in LA at least more than 75% of the homeless population have lived there for at least five years, with 57% having lived in the area for at least 20 years. Homeless people don't change cities nearly as often as people try to claim. The biggest factor in homeless populations is housing costs. There have been multiple studies which show that when rent increases so does the homeless population. The magic number is 32%- when housing costs reach 32% of a typical households income then that neighborhood will see a dramatic rise in homelessness. That number has been reached in a huge number of neighborhoods.
- AstralStorm 7y agoTo the point where homeless would hypothetically move: How? With what money? And where? These people typically have an arrangement figured out in their neighborhood. Sleeping place where they won't be distributed, minimal or not source of income, sometimes friends...
- onion2k 7y agoWhy don't we consider locks on your doors "hostile architecture"? Locks are a defence against an attacker. Someone sleeping on the pavement outside of an office building isn't attacking it.
- Chris2048 7y agoNo they aren't, locks are a defense against any kind of intruder, attacking or not.
- onion2k 7y agoIntruder and attacker are synonyms. They both mean 'invader'.
- Chris2048 7y agoNo they aren't, and no they don't.
- onion2k 7y agohttps://www.thesaurus.com/browse/invader https://www.thesaurus.com/browse/invader
- Chris2048 7y agoYou implied that by "synonym" you meant "things that mean the same". A thesaurus lists things that may be used in similar context, but that doesn't mean they are the same. "A synonym is a word or phrase that means exactly or nearly the same as another.." -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synonym https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synonym Your example uses the latter (nearly the same) for convenience, as tht is what a thesaurus if for (finding words that in certain contexts can be used synonymous. It doesn't mean all listed words are exactly the same, i.e. drop in replacements, which depends on context, or 'sense'. In this case, "attacker" is necessarily tied to the meaning of "attack", where "invader" does not have the same constraint, since "attack" and "invade" have different meanings. They can be used in synonymous contexts, but so can many distinct words, because words can be used euphemistically e.g I can talk of an "attack" on my rights, distinct from actual physical violence.
- AkshatM 7y ago> It is no coincidence that the cities that actually provide the most support and resources for the homeless actually have the worst homeless problems. Reading this reminded me of the story of the emperor who, on learning that the most plague-ridden parts of his empire also had the most doctors, promptly ordered all the doctors killed. My point is: you're taking a correlation and arguing a causation most people would consider backwards. The mechanism you've suggested for this causation - homeless people migrate to places with better services, increasing the net homelessness - assumes a lot about homeless people: that they have the means to afford travel, that they are informed about services for homelessness, that they are rational and in sound frame of mind, and that homeless people avail of homelessness services. Almost none of these are actually backed by available data on chronic homelessness! (The Wikipedia article for this is a treasure-trove of primary sources on this front). This mechanism is too weak to support the model listed here. It ignores that a full fifth to a third of homeless people suffer from one form of mental illness or another (mental illness accounts for the number three reason for chronic homelessness). The homeless population includes teenagers (nearly half of all foster children are homeless by the time they turn 18) as much as adults. Lack of affordable housing is among the leading causes of homelessness - if these people hd money to travel, they sure as heck wouldn't be homeless in the first place. This is not to say that some homeless people may migrate to places with better services - there are always exceptions. The vast majority, however, can't. It's just not valid to make the leap from "cities with better services become magnets for the homeless" to saying "that's the reason cities with more or better services also have high homelessness". > The fact that it would be good to be able to sit at a city bus stop ... is a good thing even if there are still homeless people in your city Agreed! But exclusionary architecture is not the only road guaranteed to get to nice bus stops. In fact, it is not even guaranteed to get to nice bus stops. It is the "let them eat cake" approach to getting nice bus stops: great for those who aren't homeless, lousy for those who are. It boils down to if you want nice bus stops for everyone or just those who aren't homeless. If you want everyone to enjoy nice bus stops, then you invest in solving homelessness, not in propping up barriers for them. That's the long and short of it.
- DanBC 7y ago> I mean, take one of the examples from the wikipedia article: Just because some people have a drug problem doesn't mean blue lights in a public bathroom to prevent IV drug use there is a bad thing. Drug addicts by definition take drugs. Blue lights in toilets do not stop people taking drugs. They stop people taking drugs in that toilet. If we removed the blue light, and fitted sharps bins, people would take drugs in that toilet and not on the street, and they'd have a place to dispose of the needle. This would be better for everyone.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI don't disagree with you, but most people won't be persuaded by this framing. I don't know if/how blue lights impact diabetic injections, since those apparently aren't injecting veins per se, but a more compelling argument for most people is that not all people using a syringe are engaging in illicit drug use. When we design hostile architecture, we design with a presumption of guilt and punish or problematically forbid a lot of innocent behavior as well. This is one of the better arguments if you wish to actually persuade people. https://www.healthline.com/health/diabetes/insulin-injection#how-to-inject https://www.healthline.com/health/diabetes/insulin-injection...
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoFirst, I'm all in favor of having better access to drug treatment programs, things like needle exchange programs, and even in favor of giving addicts access to administration of their drugs in a safe setting. > If we removed the blue light, and fitted sharps bins, people would take drugs in that toilet and not on the street, and they'd have a place to dispose of the needle. This is laughable to me. To be in the frame of mind to need or want to shoot up in a public bathroom is not the same frame of mind to use a sharps bin to dispose of a needle.
- DanBC 7y ago> This is laughable to me. To be in the frame of mind to need or want to shoot up in a public bathroom is not the same frame of mind to use a sharps bin to dispose of a needle. If you provide sharps bins they tend to be used. They do this in Sydney, and there are maps available to show where the bins are.