7 ms·
Sometimes, locals decide to respond to the installation of hostile architecture by "killing it with kindness," such as covering anti homeless spikes with pillow
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Sometimes, locals decide to respond to the installation of hostile architecture by "killing it with kindness," such as covering anti homeless spikes with pillows and cushions. Here is one such article:
https://archive.attn.com/stories/14655/manchester-england-residents-throw-pillows-hostile-architecture https://archive.attn.com/stories/14655/manchester-england-re...
I think most hostile architecture is basically an admission that "We don't actually have a solution to our social problems, so we are resorting to a beatings-will-continue-until-morale-improves model as an outward expression of our incompetence."
That's my charitable take. My uncharitable take is that a lot of people in power don't care, have no heart and can't be arsed to pretend to care.
- creato 7y ago> That's my charitable take. My uncharitable take is that a lot of people in power don't care, have no heart and can't be arsed to pretend to care. The charitable take is that public space is meant to be usable by the general public, not have it adversely possessed as permanent living space. Most "hostile architecture" is designed to prevent only the latter, not the former.
- throwaway3627 7y agoNice empathy you have there. I bet you would sing a different song if you were homeless.
- Chris2048 7y agoWould you sing a different song if you weren't a throwaway?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe general public doesn't hang out in a lot of the places where they put spikes to interfere with homeless people being able to sleep, like under overpasses. We're not talking "You shouldn't sleep in the public square." We're talking "You shouldn't sleep at all. You shouldn't exist. No, we aren't really going to help you solve your problems and get off the street. We are just going to make your existence as miserable as possible while you are homeless and make it that much harder for you to solve your own problems." At best, making it impossible for homeless people to sleep at all "solves" homelessness by sending people to an early grave. If that isn't cruel and heartless, I don't know what is.
- creato 7y agoThe article you linked was talking about: > The metal spikes, part of a trend called "hostile architecture," appeared recently outside of an office building in Manchester, England, that's managed by commercial property agent GVA, according to The Guardian. The original wikipedia article uses the following examples: > - The Seattle Department of Transportation installed bicycle racks to prevent the homeless from camping.[14] > - A gas station in New Kensington, Pennsylvania installed blue lighting in their bathrooms that make it hard for drug users to find their veins.[15][16] > - Anti-homeless spikes on London's Curtain Road to prevent homeless people from sleeping there.[17] The further examples in the wikipedia article are clearly not otherwise unused overpasses.
- DoreenMichele 7y agohttps://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-27ca231db82b604e391a3eec68e0de88-c https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-27ca231db82b604e391a3e... https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-627ee5187b673bfa6d413e115a679d60-c https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-627ee5187b673bfa6d413e... From: https://www.quora.com/Why-are-people-so-against-anti-homeless-spikes https://www.quora.com/Why-are-people-so-against-anti-homeles...
- hn_throwaway_99 7y ago> My uncharitable take is that a lot of people in power don't care, have no heart and can't be arsed to pretend to care. Well, as someone who disagrees, but also likes to think I have a heart, I'll give my 2c. Why don't we consider locks on your doors "hostile architecture"? Social problems are complex and difficult to solve, and just because we haven't solved them doesn't mean, for example, that people should be discouraged from trying to prevent people from urinating on their property. I mean, take one of the examples from the wikipedia article: Just because some people have a drug problem doesn't mean blue lights in a public bathroom to prevent IV drug use there is a bad thing. Take homelessness. It is no coincidence that the cities that actually provide the most support and resources for the homeless actually have the worst homeless problems. With the lack of a national policy to deal with homelessness, providing better services does make your city a magnet for the homeless population (this is NOT an argument against providing those services, just a simple observation of cause and effect).[1] The fact that it would be good to be able to sit at a city bus stop I think is a good thing even if there are still homeless people in your city. [1] https://cbsaustin.com/news/local/homeless-buy-one-way-bus-tickets-to-austin https://cbsaustin.com/news/local/homeless-buy-one-way-bus-ti...
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI spent years homeless. A. Most services aimed at the homeless would be sued out of existence if they were intended for middle class clientele. They are frequently quite terrible. For example: At a free meal from the Salvation Army, an older woman sitting next to me who had just gotten out of the hospital for a heart condition had all her stuff stolen for complying with their crappy policy of leaving her stuff in the unguarded designated area. It was cold and rainy that night and she had just lost all her extra clothes and bedding. They were giving away bedding and clothes after the meal. No one walked her to the front of the line and said "Make sure she gets what she needs to make it safely through the night." B. I'm mostly not interested in seeing more homeless services. They are mostly a "fuck you" solution. If we actually cared about people in the US, we would have free national health care and an appropriate housing supply. We have neither, then we blame poor people as being crazies and junkies when they end up homeless. Then we add insult to injury by giving them terrible food with long lines and similar "services" for which we expect them to be ever so grateful. I'm wholly unimpressed with the entire thing. The system is quite broken.
- oh_sigh 7y agoIs there a clear solution to homelessness that only requires people in power to have a heart in order to be effective?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoNo. You need a heart and some minimal level of competence. If you have that, there are developed countries doing a good job of reducing the incidence of homelessness. In the US, we spend insane amounts of money on care programs for the homeless, so much so it would literally be cheaper to just pay their rent. At least one hospital decided to do that (for some of their most expensive cases) as a means to lower its expenses. https://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ct-biz-hospitals-house-homeless-0114-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ct-biz-hospitals-hou... Two things that would help enormously in the US: 1. A healthcare system that works. 2. A housing supply that meets the needs of our current demographic instead of being designed to only serve upper class nuclear families.
- sooheon 7y agoRe: 2. I've heard there's a huge surplus of vacant/dilapidated homes selling for a dollar in the rust belt. Is it really a problem of housing supply, or lack of demand, i.e. desire to live in, well, undesirable locations? I find it hard to believe it's an economic matter of not meeting a certain low-cost customer segment of demand if all these empty houses are sitting around. The deeper issue may be structural unemployment, which isn't going to get any better.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoWhile homeless, I looked into getting a dollar home. They all had a minimum of several hundred dollars in closing costs. They typically also had very expensive defects, such as fire damage or flood damage and black mold because of it. In recent decades, we've torn down around a million SROs. In the 1950s, the average new house was about 1200 sqft and held about 3.5 people. Today, it's over 2400 sqft and holds about 2.5 people. We've largely zoned out of existence the creation of small homes in walking distance of amenities, like jobs and shopping. A car is practically a requirement to make life work for most Americans. For most Americans, housing is their biggest expense and a car is their second biggest. I've lived without a car for over a decade. If I had to buy a car to access affordable housing, that would substantially cut into my housing budget. It just made more sense to find housing in a walkable community to make my life work.
- gpvos 7y agoThe people in power are probably doing this because there are locals complaining about the homeless. So it's important that there are also locals who make it clear that they don't want this kind of unfriendly street furniture, and that they'll put up with the homeless until there is a solution that actually addresses the problem.