3 ms·
Arducopter flight controller user here: There is a reason why pro grade filming setups carrying $40,000 to $150,000 cameras are all coaxial octocopters or flat
by walrus01 7y ago
Arducopter flight controller user here:
There is a reason why pro grade filming setups carrying $40,000 to $150,000 cameras are all coaxial octocopters or flat octocopters. Even a hexacopter cannot 100% reliably recover from a single motor failure.
Personal opinion, any craft that is over 3 to 4kg and spends time over people needs to be an octo.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoThanks for contributing toward progress and not toward fear/restriction.
- walrus01 7y agoThere's valid technical reasons for having a coaxial octo within a total craft body+arm size radius of 1.5 meters as well. You can generate more thrust and carry more payload for the same disc loading area. Four large motors and four 28" CF props produce less thrust than four arms, each arm with two motors stacked, and eight props. Octos are not a conservative, redundant, fail tolerant design decision just for the sake of protecting expensive gear. Many of them still have 1+0 non redundant power systems.
- sytelus 7y agoI've held the opinion that we shouldn't be using multirotors but VTOLs when it comes to aerial deliveries. The multirotors are extremely energy inefficient, have very low MTBF, short-range and very low payload cap. On the other hand designing safe reliable VTOL is hard but solvable problem when thrown enough resources because you can draw a lot from existing aviation tech. However, Amazon has gone through quadrotors to VTOL and then they switched back to multirotor again, surprisingly. Unfortunately, most of the delivery vehicles are being built by relatively small limited resources startup-like groups. While multirotors are very easy to build, they have an enormous number of problems. I think if there was a well-funded group of 500 or so engineers working over ~5 years, there is a decent chance we can have safe reliable commercial-grade VTOL for autonomous point-to-point deliveries that can be adopted as standard. Unfortunately, this is a big capex project.
- kortex 7y agoGoogle has been experimenting with tailsitters, which I think is a no-brainer. Zipline is, imho, the real out of the box thinker. Catapault launch plus the snag line is Short takeoff, effectively-vertical landing, main downside is you need ground gear to land without damage. Main upside is weight savings for peak power (takeoff) is reduced, landing gear gone, and your engineering space is shrunk to solely the problem of steady state flight. I foresee the paradigm of winged mothership for last-hundred-mile, plus n-rotor drones for air-to-land leg of delivery.
- walrus01 7y agoZipline's system is a much lower cost, light weight implementation of what InSitu (now a Boeing subsidiary since they were acquired) designed for the defense market, for their Scaneagle. They were by no means the first to launch or recover a fixed wing drone in that manner. As you point out it provides a lot of advantages in not needing to carry the extra weight for a VTOL, no landing gear, extra energy boost on launch. It's very close to the optimal energy usage in watts for motor, per size of craft, that can be achieved right now. The other advantage of using a single motor fixed wing craft is ability to use lithium ion batteries which are relatively higher Wh/kg density. These are not as capable of instantaneous high amps as lithium polymer are. The best commodity, commercially available lithium ion batteries are in the range of 210 to 248Wh/kg right now. The best lithium polymer batteries are about 178Wh/kg. FPV hobbyist fliers who build fixed wing and flying-wing craft use lithium ion for longer range. https://www.google.com/search?q=insitu+scaneagle&client=ubuntu&hs=uvY&channel=fs&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwizuM3nqu3jAhVLrZ4KHZQVDnoQ_AUIESgB&biw=1329&bih=1011 https://www.google.com/search?q=insitu+scaneagle&client=ubun...
- wereHamster 7y agoZipline only works if you have a single base where you launch from land at. If you need to land at the customers site then you need VTOL capability.
- joncrane 7y agoI think the idea is that the full-payload drone is launched via catapult, and the takeoff from the customer's site is without payload, allowing for lower power.
- kortex 7y agoAny insight as to why Matternet is using quads still? Just nearsightedness? Yeah, they might be a bit cheaper, but now they are grounded, that's never good for the bottom line. Furthermore, safety critical systems are all about layers. Yeah redundant motors are good, parachute is nice, but what about passive measures? Maybe drones should have stub wings which, in addition to lift boost, have deadman switches which cause one to spring 180° on power loss, forcing the hull to autorotate in the event the chute fails. Ok, the gps dies, the motors fail, chute fails to deploy, and the wing ripped off, you are dropping at full speed. Well now the rapid descent causes a pressure differential (artificial eustacian tube, if you will) which trips some azide charge, inflating an airbag. It's like they are putting in bare minimum of effort with the quad+parachute.
- walrus01 7y agoI actually recognize the drone body that Matternet is using there, it's a monocoque molded carbon fiber + fiberglass body from a manufacturer in China, where it's sold as an agricultural spraying drone. Rapid descent sensors don't necessarily need to be pressure based at all. While in controlled flight there is a limitation (as governed by flight controller and ESCs) for how rapidly a quad, hex or octo can descend. Accelerometer data can be used to trigger a parachute and/or airbag system. A multiply-redundant array of small accelerometers that can detect freefall is very tiny and light weight. Most higher end flight controllers have double or triple accelerometers onboard.