9 ms·
Ballot security is a solved problem (but, sadly, I think DARPA knows this, which makes me wonder what’s really motivating this work): Use paper ballots. Scan
by hedora 7y ago
Ballot security is a solved problem (but, sadly, I think DARPA knows this, which makes me wonder what’s really motivating this work):
Use paper ballots. Scan them at the polling place for fast electronic tally.
Audit a significantly significant random sample of the paper ballots after the election, and do a full recount if any discrepancy is found.
Prosecute people that violate chain of custody for the ballot boxes. (Give this power to a non-partisan authority.)
There are open problems around tampering with voter rolls; this is done both by state governments and foreign powers. We still need a scheme to make this more detectable (and to invalidate the election when it happens).
- thepangolino 7y agoAs a European, it boggles my mind how there isn’t any for of proper verification on voters identity in many US states.
- azinman2 7y agoThis is a feature not a bug. Fraud is rare, but barriers to minorities and the poor having say are a real concern.
- TylerE 7y agoI don’t really buy this. This is more an artifact of the US (insanely) not having any form of national ID.
- hdfbdtbcdg 7y agoPlenty of countries have no national photo ID. UK, Norway and Denmark to name three in EU.
- acollins1331 7y agoWhat's so great about a national ID except more government control?
- azinman2 7y agoIt’s not for you to buy. This is a well studied, well analyzed area because the GOP wants voter ID laws to reduce minorities and the poor at the polls. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-we-know-about-voter-id-laws/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-we-know-about-vote...
- TylerE 7y agoOh I know that. To be clear what I don’t buy is voter ID having a suppressive effect iff we had an actual national ID
- colordrops 7y agoWhy don't minorities and poor have IDs?
- esyir 7y agoCause there's sizable opposition to government issued IDs. IMO, it's bloody retarded that this feature is still non-present in the US, resulting in all the pseudo ids like driver's licenses and SSNs.
- azinman2 7y agoNot everyone has a car, and if you don’t have a car, then you probably don’t have a passport, and if you don’t have a car or passport, then you likely don’t have a valid photo ID. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-we-know-about-voter-id-laws/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-we-know-about-vote...
- toomanybeersies 7y agoThat's normal in New Zealand as well. I can vote with no form of ID. Requiring voter ID disenfranchises marginalised and poor voters, who may not be able to obtain ID easily. I know several people who have no form of government issued ID. It's different in countries like Germany and France, where compulsory national ID is a thing. Rates of fraud and abuse are low enough that this isn't an issue. Technically I could go and vote in somebody else's name, and hope they also didn't vote, and I most likely wouldn't get caught. But if they did vote as well, then the double-vote would be noticed (people have have been caught casting multiple votes in the past) and would be investigated.
- thatoneuser 7y ago"Rates of fraud and abuse are low enough that this isn't an issue." How could one possibly defend this claim? If fraud and abuse were successfully committed, no one would be any the wiser. In the last two decades in the US, both parties have claimed to be the victims of voter fraud. Both have semi-legitimate claims. You cannot tell me an insecure network is intrinsically secure. That's a lie.
- zfgnu 7y agoMarginalised and poor voters exist in Europe and they have an ID card like anybody else. Having yours done could be free, if you're so inclined.
- danpalmer 7y agoJust because ID is free does not make it universally accessible. If the office that hands out ID cards is only open 9-5 Mon-Fri, for example, a voter who must work during this time and can't afford to miss work may not be able to get ID.
- pjc50 7y agoThe problem is that the system would be run by racist state governments who would construct the system in the worst possible way. (Not a conjecture, this was actually evidence in one of the various voter ID lawsuits; the state government had constructed a table with impact assessments of various approaches, then picked the one with the worst impact)
- newaccoutnas 7y agoWe don't need ID in the UK, just turn up.
- danpalmer 7y agoWhile this is true, it's a little disingenuous with regards to safe elections. In the UK you must pre-register for a single voting location, and then when you turn up to vote they cross your name off so you can't come in again.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- newaccoutnas 7y agoSure but getting on the electoral register (to my knowledge) requires no ID either. I think this is a big part as to why postal voting fraud happens.
- danpalmer 7y agoIt doesn't require ID but is verified against other records and against the electoral register in other regions, i.e. you can't register in two different places. When housemates have moved out I have received letters asking me to re-confirm who is living in the house for the electoral register. > I think this is a big part as to why postal voting fraud happens. It might happen, but it is exceptionally rare. The impact of introducing voter ID laws would cause a far larger decrease in election validity due to voter suppression than postal voting fraud causes.
- mc32 7y agoOccasionally we hear about “found” ballot boxes especially around recount time. How do they get lost. Or what does it mean when they say they lost them (and found them). I’d imagine it’s more prevalent than we hear as it seems rather odd if they only disappeared and reappeared in contested elections.
- wil421 7y agoEach voting machine could tally the number of votes but not the vote itself. The count is encrypted and only the governor has the key.
- throwawayjava 7y agoImagine a very large mostly volunteer-run event that only runs once a year or so and where some fraction of the volunteers are running the event for the first time. At the end of the day all the important equipment gets packed up, shipped somewhere, and unpacked. But sometimes -- rarely, but sometimes -- some really important piece of equipment gets left behind at the event site or unpacked incorrectly at its new location. I just described marathons, carnivals, and... voting.
- mschuster91 7y agoIn Germany, we also have paper based voting and yet, we do not have the issue that ballot boxes disappear. Everything and I mean literally everything is accounted for and if the numbers do not match up (e.g. less boxes of ballot boxes than before, or n(valid votes)+n(invalid votes)!=n(total votes) there is an immediate recount. No one leaves until shit is done, and if it gets too late everything is packed up, sealed and boxes counted. The horror stories of the US are a failure of their system, not of paper voting.
- jakeogh 7y agoExactly. If chain of custody is broken, it's not in the pile. People from all sides of the electorate should be able to observe every box at all times if they wish to follow it. Mail in voting is similarly exceptionally easy to game. Oops, lost 1% of that zip code... bummer...
- JoeOfTexas 7y agoBlockchain all the votes with layered encryption... Top Level) General population can only verify their own votes Mid Level) Counties can tally their county only Low Level) States can tally up their states only Ground Level) Federal government can tally up all votes. The blockchain ledger will allow everyone to see votes without knowing individuals. To get name and location and other data, you need to be at a lower level.
- Jarwain 7y agoIndividuals can see their own vote, and who they voted for, right? If that's the case, it would be evidence that an individual voted for a specific candidate. This is, essentially, proof for anyone who'd want to purchase votes. If they can't see who they voted for, they'd need some alternative way to verify that their vote counted for the candidate they wanted to vote for, without actually disclosing who that candidate is. Which would add some complexity to the solution.
- dpiers 7y agoIf the chain were public, individuals could look up their vote by the hash but would have no way of proving the hash was their vote.
- rjf72 7y agoYou could also add a second layer of security here pretty easily. People would probably need to be given a printout with their hash on it. To avoid this receipt being proof, that receipt would include a large number of hashes with various voting combinations also shown. The voter knows which hash is his, but nobody else does. And he's free to claim whichever one he likes for himself. To solve the issue of first voters (when there would be no other valid hashes for their printout) simply seed all candidates with a billion votes to start. Which hash is real and which is 'fake' is irrelevant since all that matters is the sum total of which we know 1 billion are to be removed.
- miskin 7y agoHow would that work? If they would get any hash that is not bound to them in any verifiable way, how does that prove to THEM that they are verifying their own vote?
- EGreg 7y agoStop it. Obviously DARPA is looking for security AND electronic voting. Why bring up paper? Hey a word processor is secure if it’s paper based!
- antoinevg 7y agoThe reason to bring up paper is that the cost of election fraud is much higher than any "efficiency" gains to be had by digitising the process. This is (often) not true for word processors.
- darawk 7y agoYou don't digitize elections for efficiency. You do it for security. The idea that paper ballots are a secure form of voting is ridiculous. The only reason people think that they're secure is that they're so profoundly insecure that we have no way of auditing them effectively and so never uncover anything that may be happening to them. Not to mention the fact that access and efficiency are in fact forms of election manipulation. The inefficiency of the process keeps people from voting who otherwise would. That has political consequences and is absolutely used as a means to cause outcomes that otherwise wouldn't happen.
- duffmancd 7y agoAffecting a(n electorally) significant number of paper votes requires the compromise of more people and leaves more evidence than for electronic votes. (In general, for the quality of voting generally seen in first world countries) Can you do better in theory, yes. Have we seen any evidence that various US election bodies can do better through using electronic voting, no. The exact opposite in fact. It's similar to passwords: writing down all your passwords in a notebook and keeping it in your desk draw is a bad idea. But it's usually significantly harder to break into millions of desk draws than to break any given site's security.
- darawk 7y ago> Affecting a(n electorally) significant number of paper votes requires the compromise of more people and leaves more evidence than for electronic votes. (In general, for the quality of voting generally seen in first world countries) If we didn't have an electoral college, that might be true. But the reality is that you don't need to compromise that many people in that many places to have a decent probability of tipping a close election one way or the other. > Can you do better in theory, yes. Have we seen any evidence that various US election bodies can do better through using electronic voting, no. The exact opposite in fact. Which is exactly why DARPA is researching the problem.
- gonzo41 7y agoYou're really close. Don't audit a sample. Audit all of the votes.
- acollins1331 7y agoSounds good, just get rid of the ballot box problems by scanning the paper ballot right after it's cast. Voting would go like this: wait in line, confirm your address, vote on paper, watch the person upload your vote, take your printed receipt confirmed the upload was received, leave. Security problem solved.
- ufo 7y agoUploading vote counts after each individual vote removes the secrecy of the vote.