4 ms·
> Will there be more tariff increases or sanctions? And then China will devalue their currency even more. So where does it end? Currency devaluation is, among
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> Will there be more tariff increases or sanctions? And then China will devalue their currency even more. So where does it end?
Currency devaluation is, among other things, effectively a subsidy for exports, a little bit like the opposite of a tariff.
But it's not exactly the opposite, which makes doing it in response to tariffs a bit desperate. If you're selling something for $100 and someone sticks a $10 tariff on it, and that makes you uncompetitive, you can devalue your currency so that it gets back to $100, because now the same amount of yuan is US$90 instead of US$100. But there is still a $10 tariff, so then you only get $90 instead of $100. If the cycle repeats you have to take $80, then $70, with the balance of the total $100 going to the US treasury. And it makes it easier for the US to maintain or raise the tariffs because China is de facto paying them through currency devaluation rather than the cost falling on US consumers.
It doesn't really work as a long-term strategy. It could be more of a short-term political play to try to damage Trump's reelection prospects. But that's a dangerous game in a lot of ways. It may actually help him if he takes advantage of it well (and even if he does nothing it takes the bite out of the tariffs for US voters). And even if it hurts him he could still be reelected if the Democrats choose a bad candidate, and then China has put itself in a weaker long-term position. Then even if Trump loses, it's basically assuming that a Democrat wouldn't be smart enough to take advantage of the dynamic, which some of them could be.
- tcbawo 7y agoOr it could be an act of desperation to keep their factories running at full capacity. They have a large segment of the population that is only tolerant of the authoritarian regime while their economic prospects are improving.
- reaperducer 7y agoThat's pretty much true for every country. I had a boss who used to say, "Civilization is only three meals deep."
- knubie 7y ago> They have a large segment of the population that is only tolerant of the authoritarian regime while their economic prospects are improving. I'm not doubting this claim, but is there any evidence that this is the case? (A credible news source, perhaps?)
- mymythisisthis 7y agoHong Kong has had enough. A dictatorship and a successful economy are the antithesis of each other.
- rdtsc 7y agoThat's a great explanation. It makes more sense to me now.