4 ms·
I work in the area of new intellectual property generation, and you (as was I) would be surprised to learn this is not actually a sad feature of the system. Th
by mensetmanusman 7y ago
I work in the area of new intellectual property generation, and you (as was I) would be surprised to learn this is not actually a sad feature of the system.
There have been countless advancements in the sciences when people have been forced to work around existing IP and have uncovered hidden benefits when working through the actual implementation.
It is a hidden benefit of the western system of IP that China et al. have not yet caught on to.
- hexa_storm 7y agoIt's true... if I wasn't forced to avoid the IP.. It would have been unlikely I would have made such an effort or this thing build.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoThe problem is that, in 2019, most obvious methods of scanning a laser with moving mirrors should be covered by expired patents from 40-30 years ago.
- hexa_storm 7y agoYou have to specify application in a patent. Riken desribed it for 3D printing in 1997 see https://sffsymposium.engr.utexas.edu/Manuscripts/1997/1997-25-Yamazawa.pdf https://sffsymposium.engr.utexas.edu/Manuscripts/1997/1997-2... but did not specify the use of laser diode as it was quite new at the time. It got only invented in 1996 by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shuji_Nakamura https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shuji_Nakamura who got a patent for the laserdiode but little rewards and fought with his employer over it.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agohow is "obvious thing ... with a laser diode" any different than "obvious thing ... with a computer"?
- mikekchar 7y agoObvious things are not patentable in the first place, so it doesn't matter what the "with a X" refers to. That the patent office continues to patent things that are obvious to a normal practitioner is a serious problem. I think part of the problem is that the field of technology is so wide right now that most patent examiners aren't good at judging whether something is obvious or not -- so they don't generally attempt it. If it's novel, then it's not obvious, is what I think they are doing. Having said all that "with a laser diode" is categorically different than "with a computer". In the latter case, you can do any general purpose computation you like. So if you have a machine driven by a computer, you should not be able to patent it if you would not ordinarily be able to patent the machine. In other words, the driving of the machine by a computer should not be patentable, IMHO. Of course it gets complicated as you add more and more machinery to the machine -- should "computer driving a car be patentable"? Probably it should as it is not just software, even though it requires software. I think it's tricky. If a laser diode allows you to do things you wouldn't otherwise be able to do and that use of the diode is not obvious, then it probably should be patentable. However, generally if "machine with a laser" is not patentable, then "machine with a laser diode" should also not be patentable. There's got to be something special and non-obvious about the use of the laser diode.
- AstralStorm 7y agoPatent offices are patently not doing the job of rejecting obvious modifications. Of course lawyer mangling of the documents does not help with discerning whether something is new or not.
- thawkins 7y agoRotating prisms for scanning lasers are old technology, they were used extensively in photo imagers used to produce film artwork for the printing industry, the most famous of which was the Lasercomp. I was working with these devices in the early 80's. I suspect there is a lot of precident patents and prior art. https://www.prepressure.com/prepress/history/events-1976 https://www.prepressure.com/prepress/history/events-1976
- bdowling 7y agoIndeed, the ability to "invent around" a patent is essential because it means that patent-holders can't completely monopolize an idea. Instead, they only get to monopolize their specific inventions disclosed in their patent, and only for a limited time.
- SkyMarshal 7y ago>It is a hidden benefit of the western system of IP that China et al. have not yet caught on to. Oh China has caught on. When they see some new IP they want, they acquire it or steal it. Why bother with all those silly rules the West thinks are so important.
- StavrosK 7y agoSo you're saying that duplicating effort everywhere is good because sometimes the duplication leads to some benefit? Personally, I'd take the "have dirt-cheap home SLA printers ten years earlier" option, thank you.