3 ms·
Free speech isn't currently threatened here; providers are just exercising their freedom of association. I also think waiting for "academic consensus" to act i
by wpietri 7y ago
Free speech isn't currently threatened here; providers are just exercising their freedom of association.
I also think waiting for "academic consensus" to act is not the neutral position it seems. Skepticism in the face of a pressing concern is not neutral, but instead acts to support the status quo. [1]
If we don't do something, more people will die. Possibly a lot more people. Academics have documented the dramatic rise in online radicalization. [2] Violent radicals themselves have described how online fora have pushed them towards extremism. So if you're going to argue a wait-and-see approach, I think you have to justify the bodies that will stack up in the meantime.
[1] https://twitter.com/jichikawa/status/1134323822096658433 https://twitter.com/jichikawa/status/1134323822096658433
[2] E.g., https://www.amazon.com/Alt-America-Rise-Radical-Right-Trump/dp/1786634465/ https://www.amazon.com/Alt-America-Rise-Radical-Right-Trump/... and the many resources it points to.
- afiori 7y ago> Free speech isn't currently threatened here; providers are just exercising their freedom of association. This is an empty argument. Literally it can be transposed as saying that not employing people of a certain race is just freedom of association. I do not dispute your point, it is just that this specific claim is meaningless.
- wpietri 7y agoIt's entirely meaningful. These people can still post whatever terrible garbage they want on their own privately hosted sites. The government is not intervening; neither is any other powerful group. It's just that some people don't want to host 8chan anymore given its body count. Not employing people of a certain race is also freedom of association. But since freedom from racial discrimination is something we also value, sometimes that wins.