14 ms·
> because someone used your property for offensive purposes, the water company cut off the water supply This actually happens in Europe, typically when authori
by toyg 7y ago
> because someone used your property for offensive purposes, the water company cut off the water supply
This actually happens in Europe, typically when authorities decide squatters should not be tolerated.
TBH, services like Cloudflare should be free to operate as they please. A publisher is simply not entitled to a CDN. If there is a demand for specific niches, a supply will eventually emerge, like it has for porn.
- bubblewrap 7y agoSure, they are free to operate as they please. And people are free to dislike the way they operate.
- coldtea 7y agoPlus people are also free to want to change the law and make it non-free for them to operate as they please.
- Koshkin 7y agoAnd there goes freedom.
- bart_spoon 7y agoBy this definition, any law destroys freedom. Every nation on the planet already operates on the premise that certain personal freedoms are regulated or restricted for the sake of societal harmony and progress. The "slippery slope" arguments either ignore the fact that we already make the same compromises all the time, or assumes all such compromise is wrong, which is a viewpoint that is so unrealistic or extreme that, at best, will never ever have support from more than a sliver of the population and will never be realized.
- coldtea 7y agoWell, we also don't have the freedom to murder or steal (and numerous others besides, like letting our dog crap all over the street, employ child labor, even if "consensual", and so on) So there's that.
- bubblewrap 7y agoSure, people are free to want anything. Acting on their wants may be another thing.
- Retra 7y agoThen they're not free to operate as they please.
- bubblewrap 7y agoOh dear - no, strictly speaking, they are not. Nobody is.
- jorams 7y ago> This actually happens in Europe, typically when authorities decide squatters should not be tolerated. How often does that happen in countries where squatting itself is not illegal?
- dfox 7y agoI'm genuinely curious in which countries squatting is not illegal. On the other hand cutting off utility service to squatters seems like somewhat different case and another thing I'm curious about is how the squatters managed to get the service itself in the first place as that usually requires either consent and active participation of previous user at the same address or proving that you have legal right to use the property.
- mopsi 7y ago> that usually requires either consent and active participation of previous user at the same address or proving that you have legal right to use the property. That's the key. Where I live, it only takes online applications to sign up with power companies and telcos, if infrastructure is already in place (cables laid, power meters installed, etc) and it's not associated with any active contract. After sign-up, services are remotely turned on and kept on as long as bills are being paid. It's not up to service providers to police property rights. They own or have rights to infrastructure leading up to the final junction box and what happens downstream is not their business.
- toyg 7y agoIn the countries I've lived in (IT, GB), utilities are not routinely shut off when somebody leaves the premises, nor does the utility company know (or care about) who is or is not the rightful owner of a given property. As the last occupier, you just tell the company you're leaving on day X and that's it. Squatters come in and just keep using pipes, or even take out new contracts in their names.
- cletus 7y agoIn the modern era in developed countries squatting is now largely just trespassing, which is illegal, but there have been periods where that wasn't the case. Most notably, following the two World Wars you had a large number of young men (primarily) that died overseas with corresponding effects like their family might move as a result and so on. So you had a large number of vacant properties with no clear idea if the owner was still alive or not. So squatting became a way of "solving" that problem. A squatter could get the rights to a place if they occupied it for some long period of time (typically over 10 years) if no one showed up earlier to claim ownership. In the computerized records era, and with no mass casualties from war in developed countries, this is now relegated to an historical anachronism.
- onli 7y ago> TBH, services like Cloudflare should be free to operate as they please. A publisher is simply not entitled to a CDN If a CDN is necessary to support the site being a public platform that's not a given. This whole "A private company should be able to act like it pleases" that Cloudflare mirrors in their news is an ideological standpoint, not an absolute truth. It's certainly possible to see it differently: If a company becomes a public platform important for the public discourse or for the function of journalism, regulation and laws can limit what a company can do. Like Germany does with Facebook. Edit: Thinking about this a bit more, I'm really frustrated with Cloudflare about this. With the announcement they are causing the political discourse after the massacre to be about free speech, while the one thing important here is gun control. This stuff happens in the US because the easy access to guns allows murderers to act like this. It does not matter whether 8chan falls now or whether it survives or whether the US limits their extreme stance on free speech as long the US society continues to accept that those massacres happen in favor of having guns available to everyone.
- Faark 7y ago> If a company becomes a public platform important for the public discourse or for the function of journalism, regulation and laws can limit what a company can do. Only if there are good arguments for this to be necessary. You didn't mention any. Just being "big" is no reason to get rid of the "free market". Are they abusing their market dominance? Is this a natural monopoly? Are strong network effects in play, as with Facebook? The best argument for a market failure I can think of is high initial investment. Yeah, I'm not convinced gov needs to write rules for Cloudflare specifically. > With the announcmenet they are causing the political discourse after the massacre to be about free speech As it should. Simplified, slaughtering = hate guns*. There is no way to get rid of guns in the US any time soon, so most talk about it is a wasted opportunity cost. The hateful and divisive rhetoric, on the other hand, seems to be sharply on the rise, with even the president making it permissible and using it to his one's ends. This seems like a way more promising attempt to stop the probably upcoming civil war.
- Luff 7y ago"We can't get rid of guns, so lets get rid of free speech instead"?
- Y_Y 7y agoIn some parts of Europe water and electricity are considered rights, and you cannot cut off service to a home under normal circumstances. see e.g. https://ec.europa.eu/commission/priorities/deeper-and-fairer-economic-and-monetary-union/european-pillar-social-rights/european-pillar-social-rights-20-principles_en https://ec.europa.eu/commission/priorities/deeper-and-fairer...
- cartlidge 7y agoCloudfare didn't cut off service to a home, so you haven't provided relevant information.
- bufferoverflow 7y agoThat's a false equivocation. Squatters and offensive people are not the same.
- toyg 7y agoThe type of squatters that authorities take drastic action against, are typically of the "offensive" variety (far-right and far-left groups).
- bufferoverflow 7y agoThat's another false equivocation.
- toyg 7y agoYou clearly have no idea of what you are talking about.