3 ms·
Her #1: "Security and reliability are more likely to go wrong in the seams between components". Cannot confirm for security. Too naive thinking. Security mostl
by rurban 7y ago
Her #1: "Security and reliability are more likely to go wrong in the seams between components".
Cannot confirm for security. Too naive thinking. Security mostly goes wrong in the very core, not at the seams.
One of her next is also a big red flag
> A big part of what I do as an engineering manager is stopping truly brilliant people from executing on plans that begin with the words “I can just do this myself in a weekend.”
It completely denies the impossibility of doing great work in a team. Someone has do it somewhen. She'll loose the brilliant guy who offered to do it properly, and she'll come up with the typical business solution. Unscalable and unmaintainable.
I stopped reading then. Way too self-congratulating engineer bashing.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoIs the world not full of great work people have done as teams? If I look around my lounge room right now, literally everything my eyes can see was put together by, not just a team, but a company (literally a team of teams), and much of it is actually very good and has already lasted for many years without fault. I challenge you to name one person who has built a thing on their own without anyone else’s help.
- rurban 7y agoOn the contrary the best works were made by 1, max. 2 people. A team helps with testing or docs, but not much else. Show me a good project made by more than 2. I doubt you'll find any.
- leksak 7y agoWhat's the definition of a good project in your mind? I believe you, and the person you are replying to, are coming at this from two different frames of mind. Is the quality of the final product all that matters? Is how the people working on the project felt during it a factor? I'm, for instance, quite happy with the keyboard I am using at the moment. I doubt, very much, that it is the result of the work of a lone individual or a pair. Is your point that the original design might have been drawn by a lone individual, and you view the rest of the work performed by other people as mere augments to that person's vision? Or does your interjection only apply to software?
- rurban 7y agoI also did a lot of other projects. Like building engines or houses or planning cities or doing a movie. Only in software you have the luxury to do it alone or in a pair. In architecture it sometimes works, in movies rarely (but such things do exist, like Shane Carruth), in engineering very rarely. In architecture or movies we call that phenomenon, many cooks don't make good meals. Or planning by committee. Never give up your project to a committee. Eg. Guido or Larry made a huge mistake. Compared to those other fields and comparing the results you see excellency mostly with projects made by the fewest amount of people. In SW its trivial to see. All projects managed by a big team are barely successful and more look like managed towards destruction. All managed still by a good founder do look great. Genetic arguments rarely count here.
- spenczar5 7y agoUh, ARPANET comes to mind. Or, you know, digital computers. Those have been pretty successful team projects.
- HereBeBeasties 7y agoClearly NASA's Apollo programme would have been more of a success with only one or two people executing it. Or the Large Hadron Collider. Or the Linux Kernel (and no, that's very much not the work of one person). Or anything else of any real scale or import.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- boldslogan 7y agoyou didn't read the part where, taking an offer without inspecting the offer could be dangerous. They gave the (real?) example of inspecting the offer and discovering it was much more complicated than previously thought.
- qaq 7y agoI've seen countless times brilliant people actually delivering amazing things “I can just do this myself in a weekend.” Now I've also seen countless times avg. people who consider themselves brilliant screwing things up. So it might be the author is just bad at hiring people ?