3 ms·
As a woman participating on HN and trying to develop an adequate income, this is actually something I wrestle with a lot, but speak about a lot less because I k
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
As a woman participating on HN and trying to develop an adequate income, this is actually something I wrestle with a lot, but speak about a lot less because I know it's a difficult subject that has a lot of potential pitfalls.
My experience has been that most men who talk to me are doing so to hit on me. It's a very serious problem for trying to network. Even if I hit it off with a guy, it doesn't do anything at all for my career.
I've read at least one article by one successful woman that openly admitted to "playing the woman card." In other words, she knew she got attention because of her gender and she was willing to use that fact to her benefit professionally, even though she realized a professional connection was not why her gender got such attention.
I'm aware my gender closes doors for me. I find that frustrating, but I'm not interested in using my gender to nominally open doors because my experience has been that it doesn't actually work. It doesn't get me access to the same sorts of things it gets men access to.
I think this undermines a standard of excellence. I think it's a factor in why the Theranos debacle want so crazy far. It was a lot of hot air valued at $10 Billion one day and $zero the next.
I don't think you would see that with a male owned company. I think the usual checks and balances were not there in part because the face of the company was a pretty young woman.
I don't know how to solve this because it's a legitimate complaint that race, sex, etc closes doors on a lot of people unfairly. It's also a legitimate complaint that work done by someone of low status gets valued differently than similar work done by someone of high status. This has been widely documented.
But when a cishet white male gets access to "the old boys club," he gets a combination of opportunities and constructive feedback. People tell him he needs to fix X.
This is not necessarily the case if a woman or person of color gets opportunities. It is socially harder to arrange constructive feedback that you can trust is not really prejudice and hostility talking.
So people may hesitate to give it for fear of being misinterpreted. Those receiving it may not take it seriously because it feels like prejudice talking or because it's a combination of legitimate feedback and prejudice mixed together and difficult or impossible to sort out. It's all too easy to throw the baby out with the bathwater.
- cishetwhiteguy 7y ago"But when a cishet white male gets access to "the old boys club," he gets a combination of opportunities and constructive feedback. People tell him he needs to fix X" This is a hateful lie, full of resentment and projection. I have NEVER had anyone mentor me and tell me what I had to fix in my professional relationships and personality. I have come from nothing, and achieved due to hard work and merit, not because of my color, gender, or sexual orientation. I've had to figure it out on my own. It is up to each of us as individuals to navigate the world around us. Grouping people by their intersectional identity group is incredibly hateful, petty, and divisive.