2 ms·
I'm not saying whether it's a good or bad idea, I'm saying whether it's easy or not. There's a difference between "creative destruction which will end up good i
by philwelch 16y ago
I'm not saying whether it's a good or bad idea, I'm saying whether it's easy or not. There's a difference between "creative destruction which will end up good in the long run" and "easy"--in fact, they're nearly exact opposites. Just look at the fallout from this last recession for an example.
(On a side note, capitalism is defined by the legal enforcement of property rights. Abolishing intellectual property is probably the exact opposite of capitalism. The word you're looking for is "market".)
- steveklabnik 16y agoAh, this is a longer discussion than I'd like to have at the moment, but you're still assuming that IP is actually 'property.' It's not, at least in my mind. You're still right though: market would be a better fit. Markets and capitalism are pretty much interchangeable in my mind, which is why I made the slip.
- philwelch 16y agoProperty rights, as far as capitalism is concerned, are an artifact of law, not some fundamental philosophical truth. For capitalism to exist in a given domain, the government has to enforce property rights in that domain. That includes everything from cap-and-trade (where there are property rights to air emissions), water rights, real estate, equity in businesses, and yes, even copyrights and patents. Whether any of this actually constitutes "property" in a philosophical sense is an especially worthless genre of philosophical argument.