4 ms·
Is there any proof peer review has increased scientific productivity? It is relatively new According to [1] "The council minutes of 1 March 1665 made provi
by michaelt 7y ago
Is there any proof peer review has
increased scientific productivity?
It is relatively new
According to [1] "The council minutes of 1 March 1665 made provisions for the tract to be revised by members of the council of the Royal Society, providing the framework for peer review to eventually develop, becoming fully systematic as a process by the 1830s."
Peer review is a relatively new procedure in the same way that California is a relatively new state :-p
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_Transactions_of_the_Royal_Society#Origins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_Transactions_of_...
- nextos 7y agoHowever, some famous papers like Watson & Crick's DNA model were published without peer review.
- asdff 7y agoYou can publish today in PNAS without review if you are a member of the national academy of sciences.
- jhbadger 7y agoNot exactly any more. It's true that it used to be that a member could just contribute their own manuscripts which would be published as is without review. But after some unfortunate cases of questionable stuff getting published, even the contributed track has to be peer reviewed these days. However members still have leverage in that they can choose the reviewers, which obviously could be abused.
- BurningFrog 7y agoThe concept is certainly old, but it hasn't been a systematic part of the "universal scientific process" for more than a few decades. Most revolutionary scientific discoveries were made without it.
- rrss 7y ago"Peer review" nowadays refers almost exclusively to prepublication review by people other than the editor. This was still relatively rare at the beginning of the 20th century. If you name a famous publication prior to 1900, it almost certainly was published without peer review.