Some journals do this. It is an interesting approach. I am however ambivalent, or even perhaps against allowing public comments directly into a paper. We've al

Some journals do this. It is an interesting approach. I am however ambivalent, or even perhaps against allowing public comments directly into a paper. We've all experienced, no doubt, the a naive but loud internet com-mentor spreading FUD on comment sections and social media on topics they simply know nothing about, and do so prolifically. It is nice to think that good arguments will float to the top, but often it is the loudest and least nuanced argument, right or wrong, which gets taken up.