2 ms·
I can't read the article, but being rejected doesn't have to mean it's bad work. My mom has helped many PhD students take their degree over the years, and in t
by magicalhippo 7y ago
I can't read the article, but being rejected doesn't have to mean it's bad work.
My mom has helped many PhD students take their degree over the years, and in the process helped with their papers. Several have been rejected, some multiple times. Frequently it was down to presentation issues (the student had not explained the certain things clearly enough or similar), or there was disagreement about how strong conclusions one could draw from the results.
For example, recently a paper was rejected because the experimenters had forgotten or overlooked an important detail which meant they couldn't control for a certain variable. One of the reviewers picked this up, and rejected the paper because the findings could possibly be explained by this uncontrolled variable. So they had to resubmit with a weaker conclusion (this is when my mom got involved).
In this case the review process was harsh but fair. The experimenters had goofed, and the reviewer caught it.
Of course when doing ground breaking experiments, I guess the process might not be optimal. But the majority of scientists are not doing that.