21 ms·
> Go turned out to be a pretty bad choice for container tech due to its awful multithreaded runtime. Can you please elaborate on this? My experience with Go is
by otterley 7y ago
> Go turned out to be a pretty bad choice for container tech due to its awful multithreaded runtime.
Can you please elaborate on this? My experience with Go is that it is able to fork/exec programs and manage cgroups via sysfs on Linux at least as well as any other programming language can.
- cpuguy83 7y agoYou pretty much need to do everything from a separate process, which is the main issue. Certain things like setns(mountns) will straight up fail in a multithreaded program, so there are some nasty hacks in runc to handle such things in C prior to the go runtime firing up.
- otterley 7y ago> You pretty much need to do everything from a separate process, which is the main issue. I’m confused. fork()/spawn() are the proper means to launch child processes on Linux. What language would do things differently if the syscall determines the means here?
- cpuguy83 7y agoBecause go is always multithreaded. You literally cannot do certain system level things in Go. For instance trying to "setns" to a mount namespace will yield EINVAL from the kernel in all cases with Go. In fact, all namespace related operations are really annoying to do from Go because the runtime is always multithreaded and you have no control over the threading except for locking the active goroutine to its currently assigned thread. This also makes that thread unusable for any new goroutine (even goroutines that are spawned from code running in that thread), which has the side-effect that the new goroutine will always be in the original namespace context.