5 ms·
Despite it being a violation today, I get the point of wanting to know marital status. But why height and weight?
by Waterluvian 7y ago
Despite it being a violation today, I get the point of wanting to know marital status. But why height and weight?
- paulpauper 7y agomy guess is, this was a long time ago back when military service was more common and people were not as reticent about disclosing such information and
- quietthrow 7y ago“Attractability” of a candidate was not limited to their skills. As in some parts of the world today we know that these things are largely orthogonal to performance at job. As rational and simple as that sounds today, back in the day knowing these details was equally rational and simple. We just find it difficult to get that point of view since we didn’t live in that time. This is the same as ageism today. “Young people are just smarter”. What do you think people will say on hacker news 30 years from now when they read that was the thinking of some of today’s tech leaders
- jimmaswell 7y agoIs the belief really that age is irrelevant to mental performance, or do we just want people to be able to continue being employed for moral reasons?
- tasuki 7y agoOh, of course it is related. Also, apart from declining mental performance, with age comes valuable experience.
- Waterluvian 7y agoI've seen that in action. An older dev was an absolute burden on a hack day moving at a snail's pace. But for long term architecture he always had super valuable "oh I didn't think of that" things to say. He was so awesome to have on the team, at the cost of sometimes having to watch him crawl toward a few lines of code. Not a hard choice in my opinion. Of course I've seen the whole spectrum. Useless old people. Useless young people. It's best to simply be a meritocracy.
- erikpukinskis 7y agoIt’s the same issue as gender or race discrimination. There are often differences in means, but because within group differences are an order of magnitude larger than between group differences, from the perspective of any two individuals trying to understand each other, group membership gives you no meaningful information. Knowing the averages will actually make you worse at assessment.
- lrem 7y agoAlso: this one is more present today. I can just not mention I'm married, while still reaping the benefits of being attractive.
- scarface74 7y agoTrue. But I do just the opposite. Even though they aren’t allowed to ask me if I am married, I go out of my way to mention off handedly that I am married. I want them to “discriminate” against me if they have the type of culture that expects people to work for 60 hours a week regularly.
- lrem 7y agoHehe. I've been going around telling how my wife is nine months pregnant, asking how the paternity benefits are.
- cosmodisk 7y agoAny success getting a job after mentioning it?
- a1pulley 7y agoI mentioned my newborn in all of my job interviews because I didn't want any surprises on either side of the table. I interviewed at six places and got five offers - two at FANGs, three at unicorns. I don't think there's a culture of discrimination against young fathers at large companies, and I don't think it's necessarily bad if there is at early-stage, high-growth start ups.
- cosmodisk 7y agoAny company worth working for would accept it as a fact of life- most people end up having kids at some point. If the opposite is the case,well, it's better to stay away from them.
- rightbyte 7y agoSo the employer know what size to supply for working clothes I guess?
- jarfil 7y agoOr whether they have chairs capable of accomodating a 500lb employee.
- gopalakrishnans 7y agoIn India, I remember submitting a passport size photograph with all the resumes I submitted during college/campus interviews. When I moved to US, I realized that was not a requirement.
- ma2rten 7y agoThat is common in Europe as well.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoit's not required but it makes you more considered.
- hocuspocus 7y agoEven in countries where it was the norm (like Germany), this is not really true anymore. For tech positions or anything remotely close, the impact will be zero or even negative, don't do it.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agostatistics? People who should know have told me otherwise
- walshemj 7y agoOnly some European countries - it is very frowned upon in the UK and might well get your application binned. Obviously apart from some jobs requiring PV (TS) clearance.
- codysan 7y agoIs this for security or something? There are listings on Craigslist that once you express interest in, they request photos of you. I always just assume these are fucked up or scams.
- 7y ago
- mieseratte 7y ago> But why height and weight? Physical fitness for the role.
- codysan 7y agoAs I understand it, resumes were more like a personal trading card with things like your hobbies and clubs you belonged to. As time went on it, it shed a lot of the details that wouldn't be of interest to employers. So maybe height & weight stuck around in a more standardized resume.