5 ms·
I have over 100,000 LoC in the public domain, in over 30 repos (the ones I'm highlighting). I have architected, deployed and shepherded large-scale hybrid syste
by ChrisMarshallNY 7y ago
I have over 100,000 LoC in the public domain, in over 30 repos (the ones I'm highlighting). I have architected, deployed and shepherded large-scale hybrid systems that are currently in use daily by thousands of people around the world.
I have a decade of checkins and mineable Git data.
I have solved every single problem that I've ever encountered; whether technical or human (I was a manager for a long time).
I have convinced skeptical, conservative, empirical Japanese managers to fund and support development strategies, based mostly on their confidence in me, and my Integrity.
I have hundreds of pages of articles I've written in Medium and my own (multiple) sites.
I have multiple sites that I have designed, and hundreds of pages of instruction, along with entire courses and presentations.
I can trot out a long line of personal and professional references that include CEOs, VPs, lawyers, doctors, consultants, politicians and other engineers, all of whom will sing my praises to the stars -on the record.
A big reason for that, is the reason I'm not extremely well-known (outside of a certain narrow demographic). I have done most of my engineering over the last decade in Service and open-source projects that aren't about making money; but helping others.
However, when I say this, the answer I get is "IF what you say is true..."
Why the hell would anyone make a claim like that without backup? That's crazy.
OF COURSE I can back it up. My SO Story is a mile long, with links to everything.
Damn straight, there's folks better than me at pretty much any branch of what I do, but I know few that can offer the depth of knowledge across the spectrum, like I can.
AND I CAN PROVE IT.
But you'll make your decision based on a half-hour, fifty-line binary tree test that a college student would ace better than me.
I want to see lawyers do legal briefs as part of their interview. I want to see doctors do "trial surgeries." I want to see HR managers do "how would you handle this?" tests as the ONLY variable in their hiring process, while having their portfolios ignored.
After a few months of this crap, I just gave up, and started my own gig. It's working well, but slowly.
I would have been fine, taking a low salary, if the work interested me. My retirement's set. I have a couple of companies that I can use to keep my toys going.
But good luck with the "Draw Spunky" matchbook tests. I'm sure that you'll get top-shelf talent, that way.
- baron_harkonnen 7y agoWhile I completely agree (and sympathize) with this frustration, there are two things I want to point out. 1. If you can do all these things, then it really won't take that long to freshen up your your white board skills so that you can solve a variety of algorithmic problems easily in code on a whiteboard. If you really want to work for at a FAANG-style place, then just divert your energy for a bit into practicing white boarding. I agree it's stupid and it's probably not worth your time... which leads me to point two. 2. Given your experience and interests, it sounds like working as a cog in a mega-corp is probably not the right career path for you. You're going to do much better in a place where your role is a much bigger part of the company, and your individual skills will have a much bigger impact. And as far as the "other professions don't have to do this" line. I worked for a while in a career that was not software engineers and to be honest, I wish there was basic, practical proficiency tests as part of interviews in more fields. The number of professionals in my last field of work that could not do the basic requirements of the field correctly was horrifying.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y ago1) Why would I bother spending time "freshening up" on HackerRank? I don't do DSA, so things like binary trees are a waste of time for me; but they are a favorite of schools. Every second I'm doing that is a second that I'm not devoting to the driver work I'm doing (ONVIF stuff). I have a VERY full dance card. Writing generic driver code for a sloppy spec like ONVIF is...challenging. I was interviewed a while back for a marquée corporation. Great outfit. Would definitely be a place that I'd like to work. I'd even have moved for it, and would have been happy to put aside my ONVIF work to work with them. They had an HR "triage" person reach out to me to make sure that I was good for the next stage. I sent them a link to my SO Story, along with links to specific repos that addressed the needs of the position (I have repos for multiple shipping apps on the App Store, and source for LOTS of stuff that is currently in use as industrial-strength infrastructure). The triage guy didn't bother forwarding it, and the secondary interview was...you guessed it...a fifty-line binary tree test. To add insult to injury, it was given in Swift, when the position was for ObjC, and the tester dinged me for not writing inscrutable, obfuscated garbage code using the nil-coalescing operator (think ternary, but worse). I deliberately try to avoid using it in a "chained" fashion, as it leaves unreadable code. Basically, I was rejected for an ObjC job, because I didn't write ugly Swift. All my work in open source has taught me to write extremely readable, well-documented code that can be taken over by folks; often with fewer chops than mine. I know that the outfit I was applying for takes that stuff seriously. They are a model that I like to follow. 2) You're right. I have figured out that "used to be a manager" is poison. I've had a number of times where I've made it to the techs I'd work with, and the process has stopped there. I assume that they are afraid I'd be hard to work with. You don't last long at a Japanese company unless you are REAL GOOD at being a cog. I was excellent at it. I lasted for a long time. I was actually looking at startups. I'd be almost ideal for a startup. I was willing to work cheap, and take risks, as my retirement was set, and I live extremely humbly. I have a huge array of skills and experience. I have management experience. I clean up real good and can get Japanese managers to commit (they make American VCs look like Santa Claus). Ah...well...water under the bridge. More will be revealed...
- ecf 7y agoLook I'm not trying to be rude, an attitude like yours doesn't really fit into a startup. They aren't looking for an absolute rockstar who believes their experience puts them in a level above all other engineers, or someone who believes they are too good to go through the process everyone else went through. They want someone who won't spread toxicity through the small team, and your numerous accolades does nothing to convey that. However, the way you've conducted yourself so far speaks volumes.
- kls 7y agoThe exact problem is most people that have been in the industry for a while know these type of tests do not reflect the diversity of skills people have in the industry and the chances that the test questions are going to reflect stuff you do every day is marginal at best. In the end we know up front they are a waste of time. Further they never, build these "test" platforms to reflect how we actually do development. I took one of these tests about a month ago just for shits and giggles and I hit the first questions and they where along the lines of what does this code do. My first reaction was, hmm I don't know where is my compiler and debugger that I can set breakpoints, because if I come upon code I have never seen that is literally the first thing I do, step thru it and break it down piece by piece so I can logically map it in my mind. Now granted they where small snippets of code, but the point is, that's not the way I analyze code, I never just look at code and map it out in my mind, I step thru it, add comments and build mentally digestible maps of code. Further just to make sure this test in no way reflects anything near reality the test is timed and counts down on you, no one has ever counted down on my while I am developing like a bomb is going to explode. And that's the point none of these interview test comes close to reflecting how developers actually do development. probably the closest I came to one that did was for a contracting group who sent me a React project with a single bug, it was completely set up, you just fired it up, started stepping thru it and fixed the bug, you then checked it in, and resolved the ticket assigned to you. It took about 5 minutes, it was literally just a sniff test to see if you could run a project, find and fix a bug. It was the first one I have seen where I thought well that was a well designed test to just see if you pass the sniff test.
- inimino 7y agoIncidentally, there is no one true way we do development. For example, I never use a debugger, and if someone asked me to work in the way you do I would be at a loss. This is why any "one size fits all" process is always going to fail for someone. Do you want to work on a team where everyone has exactly the same strengths and weaknesses, or would you rather have coworkers with skillsets that differ from your own?
- Lunatic666 7y agoI'm hiring a lot at the moment, I have multiple interviews every day, we had 100s of candidates, but not a single one had more than a getting-started project on their GitHub profile. I'd take open source code any day over our coding exercise, but I cannot hire people without seeing some code first.
- fsniper 7y agoDo you offer any engineer as a pair for the testing? Or can you except personal project codebase offers instead of the automated tests? Also don't you have an onsite technical interview process that you use to assess the candidates abilities which invalidates any need for online coding tests? If you can't answer yes to these questions. Unfortunately you are part of the problem.
- Lunatic666 7y agoThose algorithm test platforms are completely useless. I stopped using them long ago. No engineer I hire has to sort shit or filter out duplicates. I assume they know the sort functions in the language. I ask engineers with a blank GitHub to implement a small demo project which shouldn't take longer than 2-3h to finish and they have 2 weeks time (or actually as long as they need) to deliver. It gives me a lot of insight, I can see how people structure their code and if the code looks sloppy etc. You don't get a normal day at work result if you put people under pressure with these pseudo-hacker platforms. Most of the candidates have a life and I don't expect them to spend their evenings on some platform to impress potential new employers.
- Lunatic666 7y agoBut I haven't answered your question precisely: We don't offer a pair, because we don't use the coding platforms. I'd say the homework counts about 80%, the following tech interview 20%. Of course I have to trust the candidates that they made the homework themselves, but if you don't start on a trust basis that would be a really bad starting point. There's still probation to make sure they're a good fit. I'm investing a lot more work into vetting when it's an overseas candidate compared to local, but mostly to make sure we don't put someone on the street, because I didn't do my job properly.
- candybar 7y agoNone of this proves that you're a good fit, either generally at a company or specifically on a team. Empirically, tech companies where executives and managers were mostly software engineers at one point and are considered best places with best talent almost uniformly have standardized hiring processes with whiteboarding algorithms and what not. Companies run by non-technical MBAs that aren't known for software talent tend to either not give such tests and/or have ad hoc processes where hiring managers hire whoever they want based on what they like. While hard data on hiring processes are difficult to get, I think this puts the burden of proof on those who are adamant that this is not an effective way. More importantly, you need to look beyond yourself. I'm an old developer and I don't like to be grilled on algorithms either. But my understanding is that it works very well and that no one's ever come up with anything that's better in terms of effectiveness at scale. Giving random hiring managers discretion to hire who they want simply doesn't work if you're a desirable place to work and need some minimal level of competence across the board. What do you think would work any better? This focus on how it feels from your perspective is fine if you all you're trying to say is that it sucks for you personally but ultimately if you're trying to prove that this is a bad process for those who employ it, you need to make a case that there are better, more efficient processes. Every process will lose some qualified people - so that you may have been qualified, but were rejected isn't meaningful evidence against the process. Btw, appeal to special credentials as a way to criticize standard procedures is an implicit argument that hiring managers should be given discretion to bypass standard procedures to hire special candidates. I've never really seen this go well, at a level below, say, industry pioneers. I do distinctly remember the one time I did that as a manager to hire someone with a rather long series of accomplishments who refused to take coding tests - I had to fire him rather quickly. The interesting part, other than the complete absence of any sort of actual productivity, is that he couldn't work with anyone, was right about everything and his long list of accomplishments was constantly used as a reason why he didn't have to do anything he didn't want to and any rule he didn't want to follow was stupid. So I don't think standard algorithm tests are that great as a filter, but at the very least, the willingness to go through it communicates some level of willingness to do things you don't like or aren't best at. A huge part of what makes engineers successful isn't the ability to do things they are good at, but the willingness to do things they are not good at.