4 ms·
>“Only one computer was used in the past, because Boeing was able to prove statistically that its system was reliable, the person said.” I read that as ”static
by alkonaut 7y ago
>“Only one computer was used in the past, because Boeing was able to prove statistically that its system was reliable, the person said.”
I read that as ”statically” (thought it meant formally) and was really impressed by how advanced that sounded! Then I read it again and saw statistically. Less impressive.
- Tomte 7y agoThe question of statistical reliability is also an American-European (or at least -German) divide: if you look at machinery safety, the old German standard 13849 is all about architecture. Two channels, two channels with diagnostics, etc., yes, also a bit of MTTF numbers, but architectural concerns are central. The American way is using statistics to argue that something is not dangerous in a meaningful way (for example several magnitudes less likely than being hit by lightning). There is even a white paper by ABB arguing that safety controllers should be allowed to be purely one-channel architectures, because reliability is so good. Most people in the field would take that as humorous. And so the "modern" standard 61508 is a bit of a hybrid. There are still architectural elements (hardware fault tolerance numbers etc), but front and center is also statistics, namely the SIL levels.