8 ms·
The rest of the world has the power to force Brazil to save the Amazon. Stop importing soy and beef from Brazil, tie tariffs directly to satellite-based measure
by adrianN 7y ago
The rest of the world has the power to force Brazil to save the Amazon. Stop importing soy and beef from Brazil, tie tariffs directly to satellite-based measurements of rainforest area.
- hu3 7y agoI'd love to see this kind of auto-calculated tariff be applied to the entire world instead of just one country. Might as well start with the biggest offenders: China and USA.
- mrhappyunhappy 7y agoGo ahead, if you are from a nation that trades with US, what’s stopping you?
- ben_w 7y agoTariffs are set by governments not individuals.
- mrhappyunhappy 7y agoPressure your government?
- charliesome 7y agoWhy are you so interested in shutting down discussion on this topic? People are talking about and lobbying their governments on this. It's entirely reasonable that we talk about it here too.
- mrhappyunhappy 7y agoI misread the parent comment. That said, I’m curious how you’d apply an automatic teriff? Who would enforce it?
- sprafa 7y agoThere is no such thing as an automatic tariff that I’ve ever heard about. Tariffs have always been controlled by politicians.
- mathgeek 7y agoThe rest of the world hasn’t even figured out how to force themselves to save their own equivalents, with few exceptions. Any action taken across borders should also be taken within borders. Sadly with the timeline of destruction, those two may be necessarily synchronous.
- taejo 7y ago> The rest of the world hasn’t even figured out how to force themselves to save their own equivalents, with few exceptions. It may be politically easier to impose sanctions or tariffs on foreign countries than to ban or tax their own electorate. I'm in favour of forcing other countries to clean up especially if those countries in turn force my country to do the same.
- Mirioron 7y agoWhat's more likely to happen is trade wars and maybe even real wars, because you're essentially wishing for destabilization of countries.
- emn13 7y agoSome trade sanctions are a far cry from destabilization; and even destabilization need not lead to war. And while I think it's an unnecessary trade-off to make, I would further question your implicit assumption that any war is by definition worse than loss of the amazon rainforest. Look, if you reason like that you essentially say that you can never apply any pressure on others, because pressure might turn out to be too much, and might then lead to destabilization, and might then lead to conflict, which might grow into a horrible large-scale war. But that's putting yourself in a very weak position. Others may well take advantage, and you may end up in an even worse situation - on average. All that doomsday thinking about pressure is probably usually being to pessimistic. And even if things go badly, they shouldn't do so overnight; it's quite unlikely another nation wouldn't have the opportunity to reduce pressure before push comes to the rhetorical shoving.
- 7y ago
- mayankkaizen 7y agoSure, but before that rest of the world must make sure they have done everything they can in their own territories. But I doubt that is the case. Otherwise it is nothing more than hooliganism.
- dfcmt 7y ago>Otherwise it is nothing more than hooliganism. You've described environmentalism.
- fulafel 7y agoIsn't this argument essentially saying that progress needs to happen in lockstep in all countries, otherwise it's unfair or hypocritical? A sure receipe to gridlock everything. Perfect is the enemy of good, given the urgency it's really necessary to act pragmatically. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy
- Mirioron 7y agoBecause it is unfair and hypocritical. That's how western countries became rich, but now all the poor countries are being barred from this path. People in poor countries suffer. You're basically saying that they should have fewer opportunities than others.
- fulafel 7y agoPeople in poor countries also stand to suffer disproportionately from climate change. So it's definitely a good thing in Brazilian self interest too. Of course we should do our best towards fairness as well, but perfectionism amounts to giving up. Edit: also, many rich countries have chopped away their forests and it's now plain that doing sustainable forestry would have been much better even for the time.
- emn13 7y agoThat's a lovely tale, but is it actually true? The path "western" countries took to riches was long, painful, and destructive. The alternatives available today simply weren't available then. If indeed the only route to modernization were via the exact path medieval Europe ended up taking then maybe you'd have a point. But that's not the case - right? If all you have to burn is wood, and all you can grow are relatively unimproved crops, then that's what you burn and grow. But nowadays even the poorest of countries has better options available, and likely can get some help in exploring those options too. Also, brazil is not some weak, destitute country. It's GDP is comparable to italy & france, and even per capita it's similar to the EU members bulgaria and romania. At PPP, the average income is pretty much smack on the world average, similar to china and serbia (the poorest EU country). Brazil isn't rich, but neither is it poor; it has the means to spend at least a small amount of effort avoiding deforstation. And let's not forget that deforestation will likely hurt Brazil too in the medium term; trying to avoid that isn't asking for a major sacrifice. It's asking for calm, rationality, and discipline. And yes, that's not at all trivial, but it's not a black and white affair either; some improvement is probably achievable, right?
- sprafa 7y agoOr you could pay Brasil to stop destroying it. That’s something the current president, as insidious as he might be, is correct about. Why does Brasil have to suffer alone for the world’s lungs? If the world benefits the world should pay.
- wrong_variable 7y agoEven brazilian breath oxygen. What "suffering" has the rest of the world done to brazil ?
- sprafa 7y agoClearly you’re not a student of Brazilian history. Until 1988 Brasil lived under a CIA supported military dictatorship. I’m sure there are more examples of brutal Us intervention (same as there are in all of Latin America) but that’s the biggest one. Also look at this map https://medium.com/@indica/climate-winners-and-losers-in-two-maps-c89f17ef0a80?fbclid=IwAR1gff7oAyfhnAsgYPTBgojZJoH7mz0WHsEtxVul2zbwqFyt9ix7C3ZSN0c https://medium.com/@indica/climate-winners-and-losers-in-two... Brasil who is not one of the top contributors to climate change will be one of the most affected countries. Now they want to chop their forests for productive activities and they’re being climateblamed for first world activists. What I say to that - clean up your own house first. If you really want the amazon protected, pay for it by taxing your own carbon emissions. Brasil is going to suffer from your climate change activities, so it deserves compensation. TLDR- Brasil is getting fucked by climate change. So the answer to this idiot idea that Brasil should be paying for the world’s sin is - no, fuck you back. You want to absolve yourself of your sins, pay up.
- boudewijnrempt 7y agoBut Brazil also fucking itself... Talk about biting your head off to spite your nose.
- sprafa 7y agoI won’t disagree with you there. Even this recent election of the neofascist Bolsonaro was essentially a self destructive act, very much grounded in identify politics (particularly anti-homosexual).
- tchaffee 7y agoHow are you going to get China, a huge consumer of soy, to play along? Chinese investors are making significant investments in Brazilian agriculture. I'm fairly certain they will not welcome Chinese government tariffs on imported soy, nor do I think the Chinese government has any interest in those types of tariffs.