11 ms·
Uncrashable airplanes don't exist. The question isn't whether there were crashes (nobody disputes that). It's whether the problem can be fixed so that pilots ca
by skybrian 7y ago
Uncrashable airplanes don't exist. The question isn't whether there were crashes (nobody disputes that). It's whether the problem can be fixed so that pilots can fly it safely. Given all the times the plane flew without incident (other than the two crashes), it seems this should be possible?
- visarga 7y agoYeah, it was perfectly safe except for two crashes. But that's two crashes more than I can tolerate. The problem is now the lack of public trust in their work. They might fix the software, but how to prove they're not lying again?
- ethbro 7y agoThe same way you prove Airbus isn't lying?
- callalex 7y agoPresumably Airbus is still being watched by a regulator or two. Unlike Boeing which has not been watched as the FAA has clearly been gutted.
- _ph_ 7y agoThe 737 MAX will be watched by all regulators world-wide. So it will be checked as carefuly, or actually even way more carefully than any competing aircraft.
- AnthonBerg 7y agoWe must remember that repeated checking does not make a bad design good. It’s completely clear now what Boeing’s priorities and methods were.
- _ph_ 7y agoThe 737 is a very successful design and it is clear with practical experience, what its strengths and weaknesses are.
- AnthonBerg 7y agoBoeing build processes that build aeroplanes. Those processes swiftly mutilated and killed hundreds of people when the product was unleashed. The response from Boeing was 100% sociopathic. You may find that OK, if you wish. You may choose to do nothing. We don’t, and won’t.
- ulfw 7y agoWhich NOONE bothered to do before millions of people were made to fly in them. THAT is the very issue at hand.
- est31 7y agoThe plane still crashed twice which is many many times higher than the non-purely-human-cause crash rate of other airplane types. Probably even then 737 MAX is still safer overall than cars, but airplanes have a higher safety expectation than cars do.
- _ph_ 7y agoBut it crashed 2 times for the same reason. Take away that reason and you have a completely different situation to estimate its reliability.
- mtgx 7y agoBut what if the real reason isn't what Boeing tells us it is and it's completely different?
- michaelt 7y agoThe crash rate is zero if you ignore the crashes, it's true.
- _ph_ 7y agoIt is not about ignoring the crashes. But as both crashes were caused by MCAS, you cannot make a safety statement about a 737 without MCAS or rather with a fixed one.
- bronson 7y agoYes you can. Clearly Boeing Is suffering serious process failure, especially in letting two crash before responding properly. Is the MCAS the only place they messed up? Will this fix truly be 100%? Remember that their first attempt at a fix was rejected. When you see one bug, that’s often an indication that more are nearby.