4 ms·
God it's frustrating seeing people here talk about aviation. Flight computers are a fundamental part of normal aeronautical design. Asking Boeing to fly a Max
by TylerE 7y ago
God it's frustrating seeing people here talk about aviation.
Flight computers are a fundamental part of normal aeronautical design.
Asking Boeing to fly a Max without MCAS would be like asking you to write a bug free C++ program... with a compiler with no error messages or validation.
- toomuchtodo 7y ago[removed] Other sibling comments are of higher quality.
- TylerE 7y agoBetter not ever fly on an Airbus then, either. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_296 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_296 https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/9231855/Air-France-Flight-447-Damn-it-were-going-to-crash.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/9231855/Air-France-Fl...
- windexh8er 7y agoThe MCAS was a workaround implemented as a stopgap, no? How does this fall under the broad category of a flight computer as you've stated? What other airliners have been retrofitted with similar systems? Why doesn't a non-Max 737 need MCAS?
- ethbro 7y agoNo. It was a software fix put in place to satisfy a regulatory requirement under specific, known flight conditions. The following planes (among others) all translate flight inputs. Airbus A320, A330, A340, A350, A380; Boeing 777. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flight_control_modes https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flight_control_modes A non-Max 737 doesn't need MCAS because it already behaves like a 737. Essentially, most replies on this boil down to people being shocked (shocked!) that computers are currently helping all planes fly. I'm not sure how they thought AEs were getting efficiency gains while physics stayed the same...
- AnthonBerg 7y agoThe replies do not all boil down to people being shocked that computers help planes fly. That is a willfully distorted charicature. Hundreds of people were killed due to a bad implementation of a deeply irresponsible and insensible approach to make money by skirting flight safety regulation. The bad implementation was in part software, but nobody is confusing that aspect with the whole picture. The 737 MAX does not need MCAS. Nothing needs MCAS. Boeing executives wanted the money that MCAS made them.
- ethbro 7y agoIs it really? If that were the case, then you'd see people debating the relative merits of SDLC approaches and organizational blinders to letting bugs slip through. In reality, that's only about 20% of any Boeing discussion. 80% is outrage about how Boeing could have released such an "obviously flawed" airplane that required flight computer adjustments. And misunderstanding that Boeing pivoted from a clean sheet design to instead build exactly what the carriers asked them to. Generally, HN comments are pretty good, but the amount of kneejerking in Boeing threads in lieu of informed discussion is terrible. Edit: Although reading through new replies this morning, it's nice to see voting mostly sorted the technical wheat from the chaff.
- windexh8er 7y ago> A non-Max 737 doesn't need MCAS because it already behaves like a 737. If I read this correctly you're implying a 737 Max doesn't behave, aerodynamically, as that a non-Max 737 does? And if we follow that line of thinking since non-Max 737 don't require MCAS to behave appropriately then the 737 Max is not a 737 airframe and it should be recertified as something else, no? I'm in no way "shocked" computers fly and/or help fly airplanes. I am shocked so many comments defend the gross negligence by Boeing, however. Remember that in all of the needless death the 737 Max is attributed with absolutely zero deaths were because of a flight computer. The real root cause of the 737 Max crashes are Boeing executives and FAA personnel making cognizant choices to allow process to be skipped in the vain of profits and loss avoidance. I believe we'll see this, at some point, no different than the commonly referenced Challenger failure [0]. [0] https://www.breakingthewheel.com/root-cause-analysis-five-whys/ https://www.breakingthewheel.com/root-cause-analysis-five-wh...
- miketery 7y agoYou're wrong. Sophisticated flight computers are only necessary for aircrafts that are inheritenly unstable (fighter jets) that require special flight characteristics. Safe commercial, and private aircraft are built to be inheritenly stable. It's less complexity. Sure we've added fly by wire, or dynamic power controls. But those are relatively straight forward. Changing the center of gravity of the plane and therefore introducing different (dangerous, risky, and unsafe) flight charectierstics is a major issue.
- TylerE 7y agoDefine "necessary". Depending on how exactly you define it, pilot error is either the #1 or #2 cause of commercial plane crashes. FBW systems seek to reduce or eliminate that.
- ummonk 7y agoThat's not true for Boeing aircraft. They are designed to be flyable manually, unlike Airbuses, which are fly by wire.
- TylerE 7y agoThe 777, 787, 747-8, and 737 Max are all fly by wire.
- inamberclad 7y agoThe Max is not fly by wire, that's the problem. It's a hydraulic/mechanical control. That's why pilots aren't able to pull it out of dives or re-trim it, the aerodynamic forces are too much for the crew to fight against.
- Animats 7y agoRight. If this was a fly by wire aircraft, it would have to have triple or quadruple redundant control systems and redundant air data sensors. But because the auto-trim system wasn't considered primary flight control, it didn't get evaluated like a fly by wire system. Auto-trim has been around for years, and failures are usually more annoying than serious. But the 737 MAX's auto-trim had far too much control authority, and was being used to compensate for bad handling characteristics, making it a flight critical system.
- usrusr 7y agoAnd if they hadn't opted for secrecy, properly put it in the manual instead of hoping that the outcome of bad sensor readings would appear like that of a fried switch, someone might have realized what a perfect trap they had built while writing "engage trim cut-out, then work the manual trim wheel until you regain control or hit the ground, whatever comes first".
- ulfw 7y agoNeither is the 747-8. Half of his examples were made up.
- benj111 7y ago"God it's frustrating seeing people here talk about aviation" Google the 'Murray Gell-Mann Amnesia effect'. Edit: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gell-Mann_amnesia_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gell-Mann_amnesia_effect