3 ms·
Imagine a world in which a TV station agreed not to show any commercials, but in exchange would not pay the show's creators, and in fact would charge them for d
by jedberg 7y ago
Imagine a world in which a TV station agreed not to show any commercials, but in exchange would not pay the show's creators, and in fact would charge them for distribution.
The shows would then be able to run their own ads, at whatever interval they wanted, with whatever advertisers they wanted, or they could make all their money through "native advertising" (product placement). The networks could even facilitate the ad buys.
This feels like a better and more workable model. It's like how websites work, where they get to chose how many ad boxes and where those ad boxes go, and then use a network to facilitate the transaction.
And then a toy company could make a cartoon and show it ad free on Saturday morning as a marketing expense like back in the 80s!
- gresrun 7y agoSo, I’m pretty sure you just described YouTube’s model.
- jedberg 7y agoDoes YouTube let you choose how much monetization and when? I haven’t published there in a long time. But it seems like the creators don’t have a choice.
- grandmczeb 7y agoThe creator chooses whether to enable ads and what formats can run. If the video is longer than 10 minutes, they can also manually place mid-roll ads. https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/94522 https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/94522 https://creatoracademy.youtube.com/page/lesson/ad-types#strategies-zippy-link-2 https://creatoracademy.youtube.com/page/lesson/ad-types#stra...
- jdietrich 7y agoAlso, many creators opt for sponsorship instead of (or in addition to) YouTube's own ads - you usually get higher CPMs and you're less subject to the whims of the algorithm.
- dannyw 7y agoSponsorship is literally amount the perfect form of advertising. It is mildly targeted, in a sense that it’s based on the audience of the channel, but there’s no nasty tracking or re-targeting going on. It facilitates payments directly to the content creator, with no middlemen taking a cut. I wish this was the future of advertising.
- asdff 7y agoIt comes at the cost of genuine content, though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ksherlock 7y agoYou're describing infomercials... Alex Jones on AM/FM radio works something like that. They give away the show for free but keep some of the ad time (some for the syndication network, some for Alex Jones)
- allana 7y agoConsidering the lunacy Alex Jones is pushing, he'd be hard pressed to make a viable paid distribution model. His current model of selling useless/dangerous crap is having trouble since Alex has consistently violated the morals clauses in Visa & Mastercard's payment processing terms. First Data let him violate said terms for nearly a decade before the payment networks caught on and cracked down.
- TylerE 7y agoThis is done all the time. Religious networks, home shopping, infomercials.
- Renaud 7y agoInteresting thought experiment but practically unworkable. Product placements are a one-time thing and a tv show isn't shown once but hundreds or thousands of times across different geographical regions and accross time (there are still shows from the 60s being aired). On the other hand, TV commercials are very time and place dependant; maybe Coca Cola can afford an ad on national tv but a local station is more likely to show an ad for a local furniture company -and get revenues from that ad. Relying only on product placement and asking the distributor of the show to pay for it to be aired would require product placement to be massively expensive as it would need to pay for national and all local tv stations costs. The nature of advertisement makes it valuable mostly for limited amount of time and to a limited target audience. That makes sponsors less likely to be able bear the huge cost of product placement relative to the impact that placement can have. This idea also means that TV stations would only be able to air a very limited set of shows: those that can afford to pay them, meaning that most local stations would not be able to show anything, either because they are too big and expensive, or too small and don't have a suitable target audience for the show's embedded advertisement. On top of that, it would require tv shows to raise massive amounts of cash to be able to afford to be aired. This would kill any small production and we would end up with large corporations basically having to optimise the shows for their advertisement potential as they wouldn't survive otherwise. We're just going to end-up with shows that will be little more than hour-long commercials instead... Frankly, in what way is any of that an advantage over the current crappy situation?