3 ms·
Seems like the widespread adoption of USB-C has been a bit of a mixed bag. The sheer combinatorial explosion of combined cables, accessories and devices has cre
by jchw 7y ago
Seems like the widespread adoption of USB-C has been a bit of a mixed bag. The sheer combinatorial explosion of combined cables, accessories and devices has created a lot of surprises for manufacturers. I really like having one cable standard that can do so much, but I hope situations like this become rarer over time.
- ronsor 7y agoIt doesn't really help. Before you could tell what a cable and port could do by it's shape and connector. The wrong cable just wouldn't fit. With USB-C it's a toss up as to whether this will work or release the magic smoke.
- jchw 7y agoBit of an exaggeration. I have yet to hit any device failures as an excessive user of USB-C. Worst I’ve had is devices that don’t support Thunderbolt or chargers/cables that don’t support USB-PD. The latter is usually a minor degradation. I am aware that some faulty cables killed devices, but never ran across or even feared running across them.
- nikofeyn 7y agoadoption of usb is a problem. it is a complete nightmare of a standard and specification.
- jchw 7y agoWhile I definitely can understand frustrations, as it definitely seems way too complicated, I'm not sure what the better alternative ever was. Being able to plug a USB device in and have it work almost every single time and usually automatically sure beats messing with serial ports. With the benefit of hindsight, I'm certain a better standard could be made today, at least to some degree, but I think anything trying to be as 'universal' as USB is is probably doomed to a similar fate eventually.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ianai 7y agoNintendo made a port based on the usb-c standard but changed it so it’s ever so slightly not usb-c. I think the problems stem from people trying to fit a 50-polygon into a circular hole, as it were (other way is a better analogy).
- jchw 7y agoI’ve charged my Switch with third party chargers not designed for the Switch. Obviously I don’t get proprietary power delivery, but it does work in general. The issues with third-party docks don’t seem to apply to typical USB PD chargers.
- nikofeyn 7y agofor industrial applications, basically any other serial solution other than usb is a far better choice than usb. "almost" doesn't work for industrial applications. i personally don't think it works for consumer applications either, but we've all been programmed to deal with issues arising from poorly specified and implemented standards. i am not for sure why i am downvoted so much, but i suppose it's because most here don't interact with hardware at all. usb, and the associated ecosystem, is a nightmare for anyone who has dealt with it on the job outside of charging their phone.
- zzo38computer 7y agoI agree that USB is terrible. RS-232 is good for some things, and MIDI is good for some things.
- ianai 7y agoIn nintendos defense, they say that is not a usb-c port and to use only nintendo accessories.
- lwhalen 7y agoThen I'd say it's on Nintendo to make their connector proprietary so it is _obviously_ not interchangeable with a standard-shaped cable.