3 ms·
We can and we've been able for quite some time, but the problem is that doing that is very inefficient, and you would end up with a very inefficient and expensi
by simonebrunozzi 7y ago
We can and we've been able for quite some time, but the problem is that doing that is very inefficient, and you would end up with a very inefficient and expensive way to store energy.
Can't find a proper reference, but one of the most efficient way to store energy is pumping water up and storing it there, in which case the efficiency is close to 90%, and the cost of storing large amounts of energy are low. Doing what you are proposing should have an efficiency below 50% - or more than 5 times worse -, without considering much higher energy storage costs.
- EForEndeavour 7y agoHow is 50% efficiency five times worse than 90%? Isn't that a factor of roughly two? 90% efficiency: spend 100 joules to get 90 useful joules, wasting 10. 50% efficiency: spend 100 joules to get 50 useful joules, wasting 50. You could say that 50% efficiency is five times more wasteful than 90%, but that doesn't strike me as a useful metric. More useful is to observe that spending 100 units of energy at 90% efficiency gets you roughly twice as much usable energy compared to 50% efficiency (9/5 = 1.8 times, to be precise).
- simonebrunozzi 7y ago10 -> 50 : 5 times worse.
- EForEndeavour 7y agoIn my opinion, that's the less useful way of measuring efficiency. By that metric, 99% efficiency is twice as good as 98%, since the former wastes only 1% of input compared to 2%. Isn't it more useful to recognize that 98% efficiency is almost the same as 99%?
- reitzensteinm 7y agoWhether or not it's a good idea, the numbers you're quoting aren't really an argument for it. A low efficiency solution with high storage capacity absolutely has a role in the transition to renewables. Solar and wind are going to necessarily be overbuilt in terms of peak capacity. If you have enough to power your country on a relatively calm overcast day, what happens on a windy clear day?