4 ms·
"looks like a soap opera" exposes everything you need to know about the ignorance behind this position. Reality does not judder. If you want judder for some a
by Brian_K_White 7y ago
"looks like a soap opera" exposes everything you need to know about the ignorance behind this position.
Reality does not judder.
If you want judder for some artistic purpose, you can have that, just like any other reality-distorting filter.
Some shots are intentionally blurry for valid artistic purposes. Should all movies and tvs be blurry at all times? Some shots are intentionally monochrome for valid artistic purposes. Should all movies and all tvs be b&w or red tinted at all times? Some shots are intentionally too bright or too dark, for valid artistic purposes... You want stroboscopic stop-motion, go ahead and use it.
Superior reproductive technology in no way prevents you from creating a scene that has that and any other kind of artificially applied crappiness like static interference or low resolution or analog scan lines... But crappy reproductive technology does preclude the other 99.9% of the time when you don't want an artificially crappy reproduction.
Video tape was cheaper than film, and tvs and video tape ran at higher frame rates than film, and soap operas were cheaper than movies, and so the one superior aspect of soap operas became associated with "cheap".
It's a freaking ignorant assosciation is all. It's obvious as hell, and you have to be a moron not to recognize why you think "this looks like a soap opera" and see past that.
- resoluteteeth 7y agoSeriously, if people are this determined to tie themselves into knots trying to defend their ridiculous bias that smooth motion = soap opera, it kind of makes of despair about whether its actually possible to change anybody's mind about anything ever. Luckily the fact that tv's with motion smoothing are selling suggests that the rest of us have spent the 2 minutes necessary to get used to it and realized that it's superior.
- dperfect 7y ago> Superior reproductive technology in no way prevents you from creating a scene that has that and any other kind of artificially applied crappiness... The technology to produce movies at high frame rates has been around for a long time (and projection/display technology could have supported it much sooner if the content were there), and yet directors have deliberately, almost universally chosen what you categorize as "artificially applied crappiness" (24 fps). Practically speaking, it is artificially applied, and that's exactly it - it's an intentionally distorted version of reality, and it's that way on purpose. You're free to attempt to remove that filter (by smoothing motion on your TV), but that doesn't represent what the director intended. Even with "superior reproductive technology", directors are still choosing to produce films at 24 fps, so can you at least appreciate and respect that that's how most of them intend their work to be displayed? True, "reality does not judder" (proper 24 fps content doesn't either, by the way), but reality isn't what filmmaking is about. To argue otherwise misses the point of film as an artistic medium. For other types of content, I agree - reality is the target, but not in film.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Reality does not judder. Neither do 24fps movies, except when you play them back on home equipment that doesn't display at an integer multiple of 24fps. Judder is an artifact of the difference between home and theatrical display and preserving it (and giving alternatives a bad rep) is a deliberate attempt to keep the theatrical experience as a premium venue for viewing studio output. Fighting for judder isn't about preserving anyone's artisitic vision. And the people saying it is aren't even good liars.