3 ms·
I have a different take. It's not that you can't do normal HTML as fast as AMP. It's that by preventing a lot of the things that make "normal" sites slow, it ch
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
I have a different take. It's not that you can't do normal HTML as fast as AMP. It's that by preventing a lot of the things that make "normal" sites slow, it changes the whole conversation at publishing companies.
For example, here is an example conversation at a web company before AMP (and this is not really hypothetical - I had more than a few conversations like this):
Marketers: We need you to add these 623 tracking pixels from these 300 ad networks to the page.
Developers: But that will kill page performance!
Marketers: But you guys are smart, make it work!
And after AMP:
Marketers: We need you to add these 623 tracking pixels from these 300 ad networks to the page.
Developers: Get bent. AMP doesn't allow that, and without AMP our SEO positioning will tank.
Marketers: Oh, OK.
- progval 7y agoIt might be a naive question, but: in the first case, can't you say that's impossible? Show them a competitor's website with a shitload of tracking to demonstrate the difference?
- donohoe 7y agoIt does help. Depends on the people involved.
- cameronbrown 7y agoWhy does every network need a separate pixel? Is the value sell the third-party tracking across domains or something? I don't understand why you can't just have one pixel and have everything fan out to multiple services server side.
- donohoe 7y agoYou can, but it’s not universal and it requires more dev effort. Also many of these services provide different ways of covering their own unique metric.
- a1369209993 7y agoAnd in a world where Google isn't malicious: Marketers: We need you to add these 623 tracking pixels from these 300 ad networks to the page. Developers: Get bent. If we add tracking pixels our SEO positioning will tank. Marketers: Oh, OK.
- thephyber 7y agoThis is a wishful thinking counterfactual. No major search engine ever weighed obscene numbers of tracking pixels or heavy page weight very high in their SEO algo. I'm not saying Google doesn't have perverse incentives (and with AMP, they do). But it wasn't fixed before Google and AMP is one of the counterweights to web ads + tracking beacon overload.
- a1369209993 7y ago> This is a wishful thinking counterfactual. Well, yes, I did say that. > in a world