3 ms·
But all these reform schemes assume that copyright expiration is the end goal when it's really there to allow the creator of a work to extract pretty much all t
by Spivak 7y ago
But all these reform schemes assume that copyright expiration is the end goal when it's really there to allow the creator of a work to extract pretty much all the value from their work -- the expiration is really an afterthought.
I think expanding fair use makes sense in a lot of cases but I also think that harping on copyright expiration terms generally miss the point. Copyright expiration should protect against works being abandoned but those are the exceptional cases.
I think my ideal copyright system would be indefinite but you can make a case before a court if you think a work has been abandoned and you want to pick it up. All of these systems that are clearly designed to burden copyright holders and make it harder to maintain copyright are silly.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 7y agoI would love to see an explanation of why you think putting the burden of proof on the new creator to prove that their new work does not violate copyright is advantageous to an auto-expiry approach. I can think of thousands of situations where what you propose would stifle innovation. Why is this way better?
- admax88q 7y ago> you can make a case before a court if you think a work has been abandoned That's an absurd amount of additional work to put on the legal system.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoIt's actually not a bad idea if you tweak it a little bit. Move it out of the court system and into a computer in the copyright office. You upload a work and claim it's abandoned, they publish the claim and the copyright holder has e.g. six months to dispute the claim or it proves that you're right and the work becomes public domain. No human involvement, simple automatic process. Then works that have been registered/renewed in the last 14 years (or were created in the last 14 years) can't be claimed to be abandoned, so copyright holders that don't want to have to deal with policing abandonment claims can just register their old works instead.
- chrismcb 7y agoCopyright expiration IS the end goal. And, at least constitutionally, the goal of copyright was to encourage creation of works, not to extract every last cent. Expiration isn't an afterthought of the process. Without copyright, everything would be in public domain. So public domain is essentially the default. Copyright was created to allow the artist to make some money, for a time, before returning the work to the public domain, so that others can build of it. Giving an entity, forever, to enjoy the Monopoly is just absurd, and unconstitutional. Five years is to short, but 75 or 90 is to long. Based on the fact that most books on Amazon are less than 25 years, I think 25 is a good term length.