9 ms·
How on earth did Amazon not catch this first, that it took a police officer to notice? Every month or so, run a report correlating customer reports of missing
by crazygringo 7y ago
How on earth did Amazon not catch this first, that it took a police officer to notice?
Every month or so, run a report correlating customer reports of missing boxes or missing items in boxes, with all fulfillment and delivery people who handle it along the chain.
If there are any strong statistical correlations which pop up, bingo -- you've probably got a thief. Tail them and catch them.
Feels like delivery theft prevention 101, and so much benefit for so little cost.
- mathieuh 7y agoImplemented this on the UK’s road worthiness test system. We check for things like tests being completed in two seconds, dodgy pass rate etc. We actually had a leaderboard of the dodgiest garages when I was working on it
- orf 7y agoDid anything happen to those garages? And out of interest, where they clustered around a particular part of the country? I’d imagine London was a hotspot.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoIf it's anything like where I live then enforcement doesn't have enough resources to actively do anything so probably nothing unless/until they annoy off someone with the right connections to ask the enforcement people for a favor.
- mathieuh 7y agoYes, we sent Vehicle Examiners round as mystery shoppers. A lot of people seem to have this impression that MOT garages are all dodgy, but they get caught regularly. The machine learning piece of work on MOT is probably of a similar size to the actual app at this point (haven't worked on it for a couple of years). Was a great experience, DVSA was pretty much GDS's poster child at this point so we were using a lot of new and interesting tech.
- cle 7y agoFrom the article, it's not clear to me how the investigation began...could it have started with a tip from Amazon? > A police detective last summer noticed that one of the drivers had dozens of pawn shop transactions, and thus began an investigation that uncovered a theft ring that sold millions of dollars' worth of stolen goods on Amazon.com in the past six years, the FBI said. Why was a police detective looking at the driver's transactions? Would be interesting to know.
- balls187 7y agoThey weren't looking at the drivers transactions. They were looking at the pawnshop transactions, and noticed the same person sold a large number of items.
- lonelappde 7y agoDo police regularly audit pawn shops sales under a KYC type law?
- ra1n85 7y agoI had items stolen from my car one evening. When I filed a police report, I was asked to give serial numbers for the items - the police in my county maintained a shared database with all pawn shops for identifying stolen goods.
- elliekelly 7y agoYes. Patriot Act creates a centralized database of pawn shop transactions for law enforcement. I know homeland security periodically reviews transactions but I’m not sure whether local law enforcement does unless they have a reason to.
- frankharv 7y agoHere in Virginia Beach the pawn shops have to send a daily report of transactions to the police department. This also applies to scrap yards. They must submit to authorities a daily report of all scrap received and by who. I don't know how this has passed legal muster. In the article they state: "Detectives also conducted undercover operations in which they sold new items in their original packaging to the shops, which accepted them no questions asked" So now Pawn Shops are required to interrogate their customers?
- bluedino 7y agoThe investigation is a process I know someone who embezzled from Walmart and it took them almost a year to get caught. They likely knew within a month but wanted to make sure they got them
- dnjdrbdhdbs 7y agoa) The people on the inside know the weaknesses in the investigative process b) Amazon wanted to get them prosecuted, not just fired, which has a higher evidence threshold
- daveFNbuck 7y agoI often get packages marked as delivered, then when I call Amazon to ask where the package is, they call the driver and then come back saying that the driver decided not to deliver the package and instead just marked it delivered. This is considered a satisfactory resolution by Amazon. There's no shock from their representative, there's no apology. This is just a normal thing that happened. They don't really care what these delivery people are doing.
- bootlooped 7y agoI used to get this with my local mail carriers a lot. My block was one of the last stops for them so if it got too late they would just mark it delivered and actually deliver it the next business day. The post office did not seem to care either.
- LorenPechtel 7y agoIt's usually just drivers trying to meet quota, not thieves.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoI'm not saying they're thieves. I'm saying Amazon has created an environment where it would be easy for thieves to get away with it.
- one2know 7y ago1. Amazon is revenue focused 2. 3% shrink is accepted in retail, that is 6+ billion dollars they are ok with losing. 3. Data is large and hard to get at Amazon. Just getting access to a database without direct VP help is sometimes impossible 4. Compute resources to 'run a report' on terabytes of data are even harder to get. 5. Manager changes every six months 6. Devs last ~18 months so no one is there long enough to care about solving a cost issue. 7. There is NO REVENUE in catching thieves, so there is little to no exec sponsorship 8. Often management is involved in fraud or theft rings.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 7y agoCan you explain the last 8th point further?
- one2know 7y agoThousands of managers. Not all are honest. As an example, I toured an FC once and there was a still boxed perfect $9000 TV sitting in the damaged area. Most retail has a policy that damaged has to be destroyed. In reality places I have worked, managers came through and picked through it. This is nothing new for retail or warehouses. If a manager is suspected of helping thieves, they might be moved around instead of fired due to politics.
- learc83 7y agoWhen I worked at Best Buy years ago our Inventory/LP manager was fired (and later arrested from what I heard) because he was involved in a theft ring with other Inventory/LP managers/supervisors across the district. If I remember correctly, they were transferring items between stores and then saying they never arrived.
- steve19 7y agoI have worked in the shipping industry (shipping as in ocean transportation). We had a very high rate of damage to pallets containing beer. A forklift clips a 6 pack on the corner breaking one or two bottles. Insurance pays out for entire pallet, stevedores go home with a lot of beer. Theft was considered a insurable cost of business. I am sure insurance rates were priced accordingly. I am also sure our rate of theft was no different to any other port in the country.
- zenexer 7y agoThe items were sold on Amazon, not stolen from Amazon, at least in part. The article is very unclear about whether any of the items were stolen from Amazon, but it does make clear that items were stolen from brick-and-mortar stores.