2 ms·
My kids aren’t bothered by high frame rates, so personally I suspect it only bothers adults who are used to 24fps. > And an entire cinematic language has devel
by dahart 7y ago
My kids aren’t bothered by high frame rates, so personally I suspect it only bothers adults who are used to 24fps.
> And an entire cinematic language has developed around the rate of 24 frames per second — the way actors perform, the way shots are composed and cut and cameras move. (This is why an awards show or a news broadcast shot on video at a higher frame rate looks and feels different from a film.)
This is a real stretch. Very, very few filmmakers are doing anything specific for 24fps that they wouldn’t do in 48 or 60. If they did, they’d slow things down so you could see them, but instead we have ever faster and faster fight sequences in Marvel and Transformer movies where you can’t even see the details during the action.
The “cinematic language” of a news show vs an action movie is different, but has almost nothing to do with frame rate, and if frame rate was the main issue, we’d be doing news in low frame rate and action movies in high frame rate.
Horizontal pans in 24fps have started to drive me crazy. Films do it all the time, and you can barely see anything while that’s going on. Higher frame rate pans are so much easier to watch, even if they make the movie look like BBC tv.
- sneak 7y agoMost adults aren’t bothered, either.
- soulofmischief 7y agoIt's more than just a higher framerate. It's false motion, which some are hypersensitive to because it's not natural looking.
- dahart 7y ago> It’s false motion I agree if we’re talking about motion interpolation. I’m personally sensitive to artifacts from the 24->60 conversion, and I sometimes turn off frame rate up-sampling, unless the show has a lot of panning, and then I prefer the frame rate up-sampling despite the artifacts it causes sometimes. Like Game of Thrones for example has so much panning that I kept turning on the motion smoothing. But then the artifacts were so bad I kept turning it off. There isn’t a good option, so I wish it was filmed at a higher frame rate, and then displayed lower for people who prefer that. Above I was really only referring to high frame rates in general and deconstructing the argument that 24 is inherently better for artistic reasons. While many filmmakers and viewers like 24fps, most filmmakers aren’t choosing 24fps nor are they doing anything specific with 24fps. 24 is just a standard that almost everyone is stuck with, most people wouldn’t even consider it a choice today, save the few directors with big enough budgets and studio backing that they can distribute films in a non-standard frame rate.