4 ms·
> If we don't want 5G to be yet another area, like transit and roads, where the US lags woefully behind Europe and Japan I don’t necessarily disagree with the
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
> If we don't want 5G to be yet another area, like transit and roads, where the US lags woefully behind Europe and Japan
I don’t necessarily disagree with the crux of your point about infrastructure. However, in the case of 5G, why do we need to “beat” other countries? What’s the rush?
Great article from The Verge titled “Wait, why the hell is the ‘race to 5G even a race?” https://www.theverge.com/2019/5/23/18637213/5g-race-us-leadership-china-fcc-lte https://www.theverge.com/2019/5/23/18637213/5g-race-us-leade...
- olah_1 7y agoThat's all I was saying. 5G is not like other infrastructure such as roads or tunnels or fiber lines. It's a "nice to have". So why can't we do more research and prove ME wrong? I would love to be proven wrong.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoWell, you can't prove that something isn't a health risk. I think the type of research that would satisfy you would take many decades. I'm much more concerned about how 5G will impact our ability to predict hurricanes. Lives are very much at stake there.
- rayiner 7y agoFor one thing, 5G is going to be necessary to fully realize things like augmented reality, self-driving cars, and other industries that will make significant economic contributions. Getting started earlier on those is better. For the other--it's embarrassing. I'm embarrassed that Copenhagen is building a massive new subway system extension for the same money it's costing my state (Maryland) to build a single suburban light rail line. It indicates moral shortcomings of the citizenry--inability to set priorities, inability to cooperate, selfishness, complacency, etc. Same thing with 5G, but add gullibility and hypochondria to the mix.
- thr0w4w4yy 7y ago5G is the absolute last thing standing in the way of self-driving cars.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- thr0w4w4yy 7y agoWow, do the downvoters wanna explain why I’m wrong even though I work in the autonomous vehicle space? I mean, what do I know?
- stock_toaster 7y agoI assume people misread this: > 5G is the absolute last thing standing in the way of self-driving cars. ... more as "everything else is working, we are just waiting for 5g then we have self driving" Instead I read it as "there is so much else not working yet, that 5g is _not even_ on the list of important things", which seems to be more what you were implying?
- 0x64 7y agoWhat does 5G enable that 2G, 3G, 4G, and even WiFi wouldn't have already enabled? There's huge hype for 5G enabled industrial IoT, but how is this any different from connecting the devices to WiFi or a 2G/3G/4G network? Latency is thrown around a lot, but considering the latency between my laptop (which is 8 years old, mind you) and my WiFi router is less than a millisecond, I don't see the point.
- judge2020 7y agoHaven't personally looked into it, but I've heard and seen that a big point is allowing much more devices on a network without straining the network as much. 4g at a crowded venue is generally unusable, 5g might change that. 5G will also enable smart devices to connect over cellular instead of wifi, increasing how much control the device maker has over the device and probably overall increasing connection reliability. ^Although, WiFi 6 is also aiming to solve this problem so I guess these are competing protocols at this point. https://www.lifewire.com/5g-wireless-4155905 https://www.lifewire.com/5g-wireless-4155905
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> For one thing, 5G is going to be necessary to fully realize things like augmented reality, self-driving cars, and other industries that will make significant economic contributions. How, precisely? 5G won't be anywhere near low-latency enough to actually offload processing for these types of devices. (Not to mention, I'd really worry about what happens when a car loses connection.) > For the other--it's embarrassing. I appreciate your feelings, but we need to collectively get over ourselves. "Embarrassment" shouldn't be driving billion dollar decisions. If we need to channel the emotion, let's do where the needs are explicit, like public transit.
- rayiner 7y ago> How, precisely? In dense urban areas, 4G cell networks don't have sufficient capacity to enable large numbers of people to be using high-bandwidth services. E.g. if there is a road anomaly, such as construction, one of the solutions self-driving-car makers have invoked is a human remote driver jumping in. You can do that with a few cars on 4G, but not at scale with dozens of cars that might be simultaneously blocked by the same anomaly. > I appreciate your feelings, but we need to collectively get over ourselves. "Embarrassment" shouldn't be driving billion dollar decisions. If you need to channel the emotion, do so with regard to things like public transit where the need is much more explicit. Less than 5% of Americans use public transit. 96% of Americans use cell phones. Cellular is far more important than public transit.
- ckris 7y agoA lot of the 5g connection to drones, self-driving and artificial intelligence is bullshit. But there is some connection in the sense that they are sort of both unknown. In theory if you had some sort of early self-driving personal rapid transit system, or some freight variety, it would make things easier if you knew you had enough bandwidth and low latency to effectively remote control them.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> it would make things easier if you knew you had enough bandwidth and low latency to effectively remote control them. I suppose it can't hurt as an additional safety feature, but if we're considering this a requirement for the technology, that makes me very scared, given the inherent unreliability of any type of cellular connection.
- TheSoftwareGuy 7y agoI feel like I can’t be the only one that doesn’t see “national embarrassment” as a good reason to do anything. It just doesn’t feel like any kind of logical argument about anything.