5 ms·
> Theranos. How many people with advanced degrees worked there without ever catching on to how screwed they were? Tons of people inside Thernos asked question
by dmix 7y ago
> Theranos. How many people with advanced degrees worked there without ever catching on to how screwed they were?
Tons of people inside Thernos asked questions and then eventually left when they realized there was no answer. Especially the smart guys at the top who knew the most.
The book said the securty guy described an almost constant flow of people turning in their badges/fobs from getting fired by the Balwani guy. The team was constantly losing talent and replacing them... but they always had enough money, reputable backers, and positive PR to fool the rest and attract more.
Any lively business community with plenty of easy money floating around will attract a scammy subset. That's a human problem, not one unique to startups. Finance has plenty too, as does fracking, just like biotech did with Theranos. And it's a problem largely accounted for by established VCs as it's always a risk.
- wpietri 7y agoSure, but there were also plenty of people who didn't leave. And honestly, I think VCs are another good example of the problem here. They are notorious for being herd animals. They celebrate "pattern matching", by which they mean repeating the behaviors that previously led them to make money. If investors were all that good at thinking things through, they wouldn't have burned $1.4 billion dollars on Theranos.
- sumedh 7y ago> If investors were all that good at thinking things through, they wouldn't have burned $1.4 billion dollars on Theranos. Some of the investors were old and they were just happy to have a relatively attractive woman founder.
- sumedh 7y agoCant edit my comment but the journalist John Carreyrou who broke the story said that.
- pas 7y agoThere was always a chance that they make it. Every startup is just a nice wish, maybe a few good ideas, plus hopefully lucky and competent folks mixed with some money. The idea is great, everyone wants a lab on a chip. MEMS is coming, etc. Someone will eventually make it.
- wpietri 7y agoThere was never a chance that Theranos would make it, because, per POSIWID, the purpose of Theranos was not to make it. Anybody who talked like you did was fooling themselves because they liked the paychecks. Just like the Amazon thief.
- pas 7y agoWhat? Just throwing in some "systems thinking buzzword" is not a real argument. I'm not aware we have definitive evidence that Theranos was intended to be a scam all along. So if it wasn't then it was intended to make it, no? Naturally, you can say that there was a tipping point, when they started to do the scam more than anything else. But that's not exactly the fault of the investment model, nor the fact that there's a big push to get microscale labs, because currently there's no consensus about it's impossibility (quite the contrary, though it's obviously quite a big challenge), so it makes sens to invest into a company that tries to do it. Now, being inside and compromising one's integrity for paychecks is a different matter. On the one hand there are people in hard situations that change their thinking - but it's unlikely that qualified people were stuck there against their better wishes. On the other hand trying to get investors to choose you when every other company is also doing their very best to convince the investors leads to the usual fucked up borderline-lies / overpromises / demos (see also ghettotesting, see also MagicLeap. I'm not trying to advocate somehow "overlooking" Theranos' misdeeds. I'm simply stating the obvious, that there was a chance. (After all, they got the money, the people, the vision. I also don't condone how they got the money, even if, as I mentioned, it's hard to get money while honesty is not exactly rewarded.)
- taneq 7y agoWhat was that saying again about how hard it is to get someone to realise something when their paycheck depends on them not realising it?