8 ms·
> government, law enforcement The thing is when it gets cheap enough, other players start enter the game too. Companies. Criminal gangs. Or even private indivi
by im3w1l 7y ago
> government, law enforcement
The thing is when it gets cheap enough, other players start enter the game too. Companies. Criminal gangs. Or even private individuals.
A situation of "if surveillance is outlawed, only outlaws will have surveillance" should be taken into account.
- mgamache 7y agoNot really. The FAA might have something to say about what floats around the sky. At least in the USA.
- anigbrowl 7y agoI think it's naive to expect a showdown between the FAA and the Pentagon, doubly so one where the FAA wins.
- stordoff 7y agoBut they will likely step in for companies and criminal gangs. This limits to the Government.
- hueving 7y agoYou missed the point. The FAA will allow government surveillance but not criminal orgs.
- anigbrowl 7y agoThe GP talked about people entering the surveillance game in general, not necessarily operating their own blimps. Smaller outfits will find ways to game the existing rules and add surveillance capability thereto.
- ptero 7y agoFAA wields enormous (usually dictatorial) powers in things that refer to safe flight and will easily trump Pentagon there. It would not lift a finger on privacy, but will likely enforce that all such balloons carry transponders. This is not a consolation here, but just a note that in its fiefdom FAA will win.
- NikkiA 7y agoThe pentagon has free reign to pretty much define any TFR and the FAA just has to accept it.
- ptero 7y agoCan you provide some examples? I think FAA is usually involved at all stages and should those planned TFR be a pain safety-wise (e.g. encroach on a landing pattern), Pentagon is told to come back with a better plan. Those two organizations work together all the time and know what works, so such conflicts are rare, but in a direct confrontation I think FAA easily wins.
- base698 7y ago65,000 ft is above their jurisdiction.
- mgamache 7y agois it really? Not doubting, but looking for a reference. The balloon has to get to 65,000 ft. So launches are covered?
- WarOnPrivacy 7y ago>The thing is when it gets cheap enough, other players start enter the game too. Companies. Criminal gangs. >Or even private individuals. This last is the worthwhile part. The problem isn't surveillance, it's disproportional surveillance. That is, people in power can only control the public while they retain a monopoly on power. Since bulk surveillance is coming, the best outcome is equal surveillance and equal access. Postscript: Privacy laws tend to lock you and I away from data, not powerful people who ruin lives.
- wool_gather 7y agoAnybody interested in this train of thought should check out David Brin's The Transparent Society, in which he makes the same argument. I haven't re-read it in a while; it may be outdated technically, but I think that the philosophical thrust will still be applicable.