3 ms·
> Instead, I think what we need is a process for the USPTO to grant third parties permission to use a work when a good faith effort has been made to determine a
by jandrese 7y ago
> Instead, I think what we need is a process for the USPTO to grant third parties permission to use a work when a good faith effort has been made to determine and contact the copyright holder. In my view, this would involve involve paying of statutory license fees to the USPTO who will hold them in escrow.
In this case isn't the government stealing from the copyright holder and/or public domain? If I use a presumably abandoned work as a jumping off point to a billion dollar franchise and then the original copyright holder comes out of the woodwork to claim 50% of everything I've made will the government escrow cover that? What if two people come out claiming to own the copyright? This solution seems to have all of the problems of the current system and offer little to fix the problem.
I agree that the old paper recordkeeping was not scalable to the modern world, but an online registry of works doesn't seem out of the question. It's exactly the sort of thing the web should be good for. Renewals could also be done online. For easy lookup a standardized copyright numbering system could be optionally added to each work similar to an ISBN.
The hardest problem would be validating that people actually have rights to what they claim on the service. There would undoubtedly be a cottage industry of people seeking out forgotten works and registering them under their name for the license fees. A modest fee for renewal should help reduce that problem and also stiff penalties for knowingly stealing other peoples work. The fees would be used to run the massive server farm necessary for keeping all of those records available. I would also suggest that a modest copyright term, say 15 years or so would automatically be applied to any work and you would only need to register if you're planning to renew the work after the original term is up. We don't need people writing bots that automatically register every forum post or email or google query they make, because there will definitely be people who try that shit just to troll for licensing dollars.
- pavon 7y ago> If I use a presumably abandoned work as a jumping off point to a billion dollar franchise and then the original copyright holder comes out of the woodwork to claim 50% of everything I've made will the government escrow cover that? It would be the same as any other statutory licensing system, where once the government grants you permission to use the work, and you pay the statutory fees, the copyright holder has no claim to any rights in your derivative works. The only right they have at that point is to the fees, and it is between them and the government as to whether they are the rightful copyright holder, no reason to involve you. Again, I think this would work smoother if all works had say 20 years of full copyright protection, just like today, and then another 20 subject to statutory licensing. Then in that second period there would be no dispute over whether you, the third party, had the right to use the work, the only dispute is over who gets the statutory fees, and the government agrees to be the middle man in situations where that is not clear, so that uncertainty of ownership won't stifle use. > In this case isn't the government stealing from the copyright holder and/or public domain? Stealing implies that either the copyright holder or the public have some inherit ownership right in the work, however their rights are only what the law grants them. In this system, works would not enter the public domain until after the second period is over, so the public domain has no rightful claim to them (orphaned or not). In the second phase of copyright, the holder would no longer have absolute right to control the work, and only limited rights in setting prices. Anyone could redistribute or make derivative works (subject to trademark law, etc), as long as they paid the statutory fees. If a copyright holder abandons the work, then you cannot blame the government for treating the fees similar to other abandoned property.