5 ms·
I took partial differential equations as an undergrad, which thoroughly kicked my ass. There was a lot of stuff that I found confusing, and so once I finally u
by tombert 7y ago
I took partial differential equations as an undergrad, which thoroughly kicked my ass. There was a lot of stuff that I found confusing, and so once I finally understood it, I made a Youtube video explaning separation of variables for the clamped heat equation, and posted it hoping that either I or someone else could benefit from that.
A few weeks later, I got a private Youtube message from someone claiming that he was a PhD student that was willing to pay me $600 to do his PDE homework for him. As a broke college kid, $600 might as well have been $600,000 to me at the time, so I eagerly agreed, but shortly after realized that this was incredibly unethical and I started feeling guilty. Before he could send me the money, I came up with an excuse saying something like "my computer caught on fire".
Looking back, it was sort of a surreal thing; I wouldn't have thought that a PhD'd person would need a lot of help from some gauky undergrad making a crappy tutorial with Mathtype and screen recording software. I guess this stuff must be pretty prevalent though...maybe if I had known about it I wouldn't have dropped out of school the next semester :) .
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoI superficially like the idea of a meritocracy, where hard work and success move you up the in the order of things. Then I remember cheating, the difficulty of quantifying success, the shifting nature of what kind of success we want to reward, yada yada. Now I am more in the egalitarian camp, where I want everyone to have enough to be comfortable, but I still want there to be rewards for being successful. Some sort of egalitarian free for all, where everyone is a winner, but some win more than others. I have this thought that keeps popping into my head. N people are on an island. On the island is a tree that makes enough X units of food, where X is greater than N, and each unit of food is enough to sustain one person. The N people work together to make sure that everyone gets at least 1 unit of food, and X - N units left over are split up by some fair enough competition.
- ergothus 7y agoOne argument in favor of UBI I found particularly thought-provoking (paraphrasing): "UBI isn't anti-capitalist, UBI enables capitalism. By providing the basic requirements for living, it allows everyone to actually participate in the competition instead of keeping the poor too busy and too at-risk to attempt business ventures." I'm still undecided on UBI, but that argument definitely made me think of things from some different angles.
- xwdv 7y ago“Basic requirements for living” though isn’t a pile of cash; it’s food, water, shelter, clothing and some form of transportation. I’ve yet to see a UBI scheme proposed that provides those things to people so they can spend their time pursuing other ventures.
- harryh 7y agoHomer Simpson's brain would like to have a word with you: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dgct3Jn8pFA&t=8s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dgct3Jn8pFA&t=8s
- horsawlarway 7y agoI understand where you're coming from, but the idea that every person has the same basic requirements falls flat immediately. Take just a small sample of different folks Person A: Single 35yo female with high blood pressure Person B: Married 62yo with dementia Person C: 14yo with Type 1 diabetes Person D: Married 36yo with a knee replacement Person E: Single 21yo attending college That's 5 people. Not a one of them is all that rare. They each require some form of the goods you've described, but the actual needs of each person vary A LOT. The 21yo in college probably doesn't need a car. The guy with dementia probably can't have a car. The 36yo will need a form of transportation that accommodates the knee. The food requirements of the person with diabetes and the person with high blood pressure are specific and different. The meds those two people need are specific and different. And that's just 5 people with relatively common situations. Once you actually start trying to get those "basic requirements for living" to work for the entire populace you quickly realize that "basic" is not actually basic, and usually the person best able to decide what they need is... drumroll... that person. So instead of a condescending, authoritarian approach where the government strictly provides goods, UBI tries to give each person the ability to choose for themselves what they need, and how they'd like to prioritize it. ----- Now, I still have a lot of problems with UBI, and I'm fairly convinced it won't work. But I do strongly believe that the "pile of cash" approach is the most egalitarian and efficient solution to meet the specific needs of the incredibly varied population if UBI is something we're going to try.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoIf there's enough food to sustain everyone, why is competition necessary? Is everyone just fighting over the chance to get fat, or would the winners have better nutrition and gain a permanent advantage, even if they won initially due to luck? What makes the competition fair? The guy who's good at chess wants a chess competition. The ex-basketball player wants a jumping competition. Would a fair competition be one that plays to existing strengths, or one that everyone is equally likely to win? If it's the first, how do you decide whose merits are most worthy of being rewarded? If it's the second, where does merit come in?
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoHaven't you ever played a game, won, and felt good about winning? If not, try it sometime. You may find that winning is fun. It's even more fun when the other players like you enough to play with you again. What sucks is winning when the losers starve to death.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoI like winning. It's fun without the loser eating less because I won.
- eridius 7y agoYou can play a game without adding an external reward to it.
- downrightmike 7y agoThere is a psychological part where doing things makes you happy, eventually you exhaust that and the amount of money is the only measure you have. That is what makes people greedy even if they have billions, they still want more. Just how we evolved.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoIf the goal is to keep score, you can do that directly. A score tally sounds a lot more satisfying than a hoard of rotting food.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoWhen I was an undergrad, I too struggled with PDEs. If I hadn't taken it in undergrad and it became a requirement in grad school, it wouldn't have been any easier for me. PhD students are just people who stayed in school longer and started doing research. Someone who is still taking classes like PDEs probably hasn't done much research yet.
- tombert 7y agoYeah, that's fair enough; I guess as an undergrad (and even now, though to a lesser extent), it's easy to have this romanticized idea of "PhDs are the best of the best of the best", especially in the coolest field ever (math); I guess it was easy for me to forget that these are still people. Still, kind of unethical to ask some kid from Youtube to do your homework for you.