4 ms·
I wish we would bring back manual renewals for copyright. I get that publishers thought it was a hassle to have to do the work for stuff they had not published
by jandrese 7y ago
I wish we would bring back manual renewals for copyright. I get that publishers thought it was a hassle to have to do the work for stuff they had not published in decades and had no intention of ever reprinting, but that's kind of the point isn't it? Why is the government locking away works that the original rightsholders no longer care about? The copyright system is supposed to serve the common good, what common good is there from locking away works simply because the original owner lost interest in them? Or worse, when nobody knows who or where the original owner is.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kbutler 7y agoGrant short-term copyright for any written works, but require registration and periodic renewal for longer duration, with increasing fees for subsequent renewals.
- TomMarius 7y agoI would be in favor of continuously increasing percentage of revenue based tax, not some arbitrary fee.
- jandrese 7y agoThat's kind of hard to measure though. It would require a LOT of government auditing to catch cheaters. Like Hollywood movies would never have to pay to be renewed because they never make any net revenue.
- riffic 7y agohttps://www.wikihow.com/Write-Your-Congressional-Representative https://www.wikihow.com/Write-Your-Congressional-Representat...
- pavon 7y agoI'm not a big fan of copyright renewals. There are two arguments I here in favor of them. 1) It allows orphaned works to enter the public domain sooner. 2) For works that are renewed, it provides information on who the copyright holder is and how they can be contacted. On the first point, I think that renewal is a poor proxy for determining which works are are orphaned or no longer have commercial value, instead just showing which copyright holders have the most diligent book keeping. Large number of published works will loose copyright protection just due to oversight. A simple mistake shouldn't result in disproportionate consequences (loss of decades of revenue). At the same time other works that are no longer available on the market will be prevented from entering public domain by companies that just renew everything. Furthermore, historically, the USPTO has done a poor job of keeping (and making accessible) records of which works were renewed, and which weren't. Anyone who wants to use an orphaned work has needed to prove a negative, which is difficult to do, so most assume that everything is still copyrighted to avoid liability anyway. Lastly, just because someone has registered a work (for renewal or otherwise) is not proof that they hold copyright on that work. People have spent decades trying to determine the rightful owner of a work so they can license it, even when it was registered. Instead, I think what we need is a process for the USPTO to grant third parties permission to use a work when a good faith effort has been made to determine and contact the copyright holder. In my view, this would involve involve paying of statutory license fees to the USPTO who will hold them in escrow. If the owner is eventually determined, they can claim the money, and if no one claims it after some time it goes to fund the endowment for the arts. This would allow the public access to orphaned and disputed works again, and would encourage registration without the strong consequences for forgetting. I would actually take this a step further and declare that all works are subject to statutory licensing for the second half of their copyright duration, not just orphaned works, and the above process would just be a fallback when the copyright holder can't be contacted. And of course, would shorten the copyright duration as well.
- DuskStar 7y ago> On the first point, I think that renewal is a poor proxy for determining which works are are orphaned or no longer have commercial value, instead just showing which copyright holders have the most diligent book keeping. Large number of published works will loose copyright protection just due to oversight. A simple mistake shouldn't result in disproportionate consequences (loss of decades of revenue). At the same time other works that are no longer available on the market will be prevented from entering public domain by companies that just renew everything. So in other words, renewing should cost a decent amount of money, so that not every work is worth renewing? I don't really see the fact that people will let things enter the public domain sooner as a downside, even if it would (theoretically) have earned them more money. If they aren't organized enough to renew the copyright, why would they be organized enough to actually use the work?
- einpoklum 7y agoThe copyright system was never intended to serve the common good. Rather, its basis was the "Statute of Anne". It was about censorship and regulation of the book trade. For more information: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_of_Anne https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_of_Anne Now, it said already back then that its intent was the "encouragement of learning", but the intent was very thinly veiled.