5 ms·
I'm guessing at _least_ 15 out of those 16 people knew that deletionism has nothing to do with the cost of disk space. It was more a vote of frustration over t
by ghshephard 16y ago
I'm guessing at _least_ 15 out of those 16 people knew that deletionism has nothing to do with the cost of disk space. It was more a vote of frustration over the overreaching that occurs when seminal figures like _why have their Wikipedia Page deleted. There are _shades_ of notability, and I agree that someone has to make a call:
Not: o How many times have I sneezed today.
Barely: o The Ties of my Local Anchorman
Notable: o Pokemon Characters, _why, Canada
Unfortunately, the deletionists have moved from "Not" to "Barely" and in some cases have started yanking out very clearly notable pages. The upvote, above, is, I suspect, people expressing that frustration.
- tptacek 16y agoYour anti-deletionism argument is insufficiently doctrinaire: it acknowledges that there may exist some true statements that might merit deletion from Wikipedia. Many inclusionists find that idea repellant. For whatever it's worth: _why has a page. Nobody ever tried to delete Canada. Pokemon characters have pages because they are easily verified.
- celoyd 16y agoYour anti-deletionism argument is insufficiently doctrinaire Having just appreciated your criticism of a sarcastic and unhelpful comment, I hope you’re not turning to easy point-scoring yourself.
- tptacek 16y agoI'm flattered that you think I'm taking a high road here, but I'm really just irritated at the fact that the comment was content-free snark.
- StavrosK 16y agoYou have hit my motives for the comment on the head, thank you for the elaboration for those who might mistake my intent.
- ghaff 16y agoNotability is a really tough concept in the context of Wikipedia for a couple of reasons. The first is that notability is in no small part a function of scale. Many things that would not make the cut in a global, space-limited encyclopedia are nevertheless in Wikipedia (properly) because they're notable to some niche of contributors/readers. But once you start having articles about some episode of a 1980s TV show, how can you, in good conscience, say that an article about a selectman in a small town or an athlete at a small college isn't also notable? And verifiability gets interesting in this context. Effectively, verifiability puts disproportionate weight on verifiability through traditional media. Thus, presumably, school newspapers and the like would be considered an indication that something is indeed notable.
- tptacek 16y agoBecause the selectman wasn't written about in a reliable secondary source, and the TV show was. What, you say, the selectman appeared in a newspaper article? Congratulations: you're done. Cite it. The article will stick. Someone will inevitably try to delete it; you'll point to the sourcing at the bottom of the article, and you'll win the AfD. It's really not complicated. It is also NOT ABOUT "FAIR". Notability and verifiability aren't value judgements about subjects. They are judgements about the COMPATIBILITY of subjects with Wikipedia.
- kolmogorovcmplx 16y agoThis continuous lowering of the "delete or not" bar should be pretty obvious to anybody who has followed Wikipedia for some time. I used to be of the opinion that it was justified, but has realised lately that it has become a tool for political censorship. Some of the editing cliques have become very adept at suppressing unwanted views with dubious, but to many persuasive, application of the verifiability and notability policies.
- tptacek 16y agoIt should be very, very easy for you to produce a URL illustrating this phenomenon for those of us who are skeptical of it.
- kolmogorovcmplx 16y agoI have seen this happen on several subjects, but as it has been over a year since I actively participated and followed Wikipedia internals, I cannot immediately give you a particular example. My observation of this abuse of policy has been as a bystander by the way. I've never actively edited any articles on these subjects. Typical subjects where there most certainly are well organized and ideologically motivated editorial cliques include US foreign policy, anything to do with Israel, Turkey and its history, anything relating to Islam etc. Abuse of the notability policy is just one, but very effective, tool for censoring and controlling the content though.