3 ms·
> We really need mandatory ethics courses in CS. Voice recognition isn't really possible without someone listening to train the system. If the option is "don'
by londons_explore 7y ago
> We really need mandatory ethics courses in CS.
Voice recognition isn't really possible without someone listening to train the system.
If the option is "don't have a voice assistant at all" or "have a voice assistant that sometimes has a human listening", I suspect the public would mostly choose the latter.
When you call a company helpline and get connected to a human rather than a robo-voice, most people are happy about it. It's curious they treat voice assistants the other way round.
- ctz 7y ago> Voice recognition isn't really possible without someone listening to train the system. IBM ViaVoice was released in 1997, and did standalone voice recognition to an acceptable degree from my recollection (after a couple of hours training).
- oulipo 7y agoThis is what we do at https://snips.ai https://snips.ai, we are building the first 100% on-device and private-by-design Voice AI so that you don't have to choose between having an assistant and having your privacy! It works in english, french, german, japanese, spanish, italian, and more coming soon! It is 100% free for makers!
- icebraining 7y ago> If the option is "don't have a voice assistant at all" or "have a voice assistant that sometimes has a human listening" It's false that those are the only choices. You don't have to use the whole pool of users as unwitting guinea pigs of your system. You can use a voice assistant that was previously trained on a well informed and hopefully paid pool of volunteers.
- cameronbrown 7y agoThe trade-off there is obviously due to logistics your pool of volunteers isn't going to be as representative of a global population so training data quality is going to be worse.
- mtgx 7y ago> I suspect the public would mostly choose the latter. I'd like a citation for that. I don't think assistants are such a significant feature in most people's lives that they couldn't live without it. Sure, people with various handicaps may find them super useful, but that's different, for the same reason I or most people don't need the hidden and usually disabled by default accessibility features in operating systems.