5 ms·
Can those of us who were terrified of student loans and who scrimped through on extra hardship to avoid them have some of that money?
by whatshisface 7y ago
Can those of us who were terrified of student loans and who scrimped through on extra hardship to avoid them have some of that money?
- minikites 7y agoDo you want medical treatment when you're not injured? You should be thankful you avoided hardship.
- Loughla 7y agoI'm genuinely not trying to be hateful, and these next sentences are not meant to be as shitty sounding as they might sound, but I don't know how else to phrase this. I have this question when I hear people like you say things like that: Why can't you just support policies that help other people without worrying about yourself? Is 'I had it bad so everyone else should, too' really where you want to live?
- niij 7y agoBecause people with personal responsibility paid for themselves AND are now expected to pay for others through their taxes. Why should I be expected to pay for your poor financial decisions?
- Accacin 7y agoHonestly, this is the big difference I think in American and EU thinking (to be incredibly general). I am paying back my UK student loan, and if a party like Labour once again said they were going to make university tuition free again, I would vote for them in a heartbeat. I don't care that I'd still have to pay, I want my country to be better. To be a bit melodramatic, yours and my ancestors sacrificed a lot to be where we are now. I'm just glad the only thing I'm likely going to need to sacrifice is some extra tax.
- refurb 7y agoYou're comparing different things. If you had just paid off your student loans by diligently saving and the Labour party said they'll forgive the debt of your classmates who partied it up and never paid back their loans would you feel the same?
- Accacin 7y agoI get your point, but it doesn't work like that in the UK so your example wouldn't happen. However, if it did.. I don't think I'd be annoyed but that's hard to say until it happens. In some respects, it would actually work in a similar way though. In their statement, they said that they'd forgive the student debt of those currently studying, but not those who had already finished (like me). For this I can safely say that I'd still be incredibly happy. By the way, I'm not trying to paint American's in a negative light. I'm a big fan of America, but it is a difference as far as I can tell, although which line of thinking is right is incredibly hard to say.
- refurb 7y agoThe distinction between the two scenarios is important though, because if the US gov't was to institute changes to college where newly attending students got a break that earlier students didn't, sure you'd get pushback, but not nearly as much as just forgiving existing student loans. The US is more individualistic than the UK, but we're not entirely heartless bastards.
- niij 7y agoI see what you mean by trying to improve your own country. But consider this: college education is not for everyone. If someone doesn't decide to go to college and still makes a good living as a tradesman or even unskilled worker, why should they be taxed to subsidize someone else's college? Why not just tax less and let people make their own decisions with how the money they've earned is spent. Every time you create a new tax it's one less choice (freedom) someone has in their life.
- 7y ago
- mempko 7y agoBy personal responsibility, I'm guessing you mean saving and not getting into debt. It is rather strange that you propose everyone does this, since A) money IS debt. The money in your savings account, that you are so responsible with, is money that originated as a bank loan, or government debt. B) If everyone is responsible, then you end up with the paradox of thrift where you get a deflation spiral and economy tanks. So thank those who are being "irresponsible" for your savings, because without them you would have no income. If you want to know more about how money works, read the great resource provided by the Bank of England. https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/quarterly-bulletin/2014/q1/money-creation-in-the-modern-economy https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/quarterly-bulletin/2014/q1/m... Or watch this great video by David Graeber, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxJW7hl8oqM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxJW7hl8oqM
- niij 7y agoAre you arguing that I should be forced to spend my money in a certain way else the government should take it away? Why is what I do with my own money any of your or the government's business? > money IS debt. The money in your savings account, that you are so responsible with, is money that originated as a bank loan, or government debt. You're going to need to explain a bit more here. Arguing that money that was _formerly_ debt is still debt when in my possession is gonna take some strong convincing :)
- mempko 7y agoDid you check out the video? If you want more detail, read the link I posted from the bank England
- niij 7y agoI honestly hadn't but just went back and watched it not. Interesting explanation there, thanks for sharing. So the point is, like you pointed out, money is just government debt. Let's say I pay for my education in cash directly to the university, without taking any private or public sector loans. Would that cause a "deflation spiral" as you put it? It's just bypassing a middleman that is unnecessary if I had saved that cash over time to be able to pay for the goods/service I'm receiving (in this case: an education). So, yes, while money may be government debt, I don't see how avoiding private/public loans would have negative economic impacts overall on society.
- minikites 7y agoBecause that's how civilization operates. Why should I subsidize someone else's electric car? Why should I pay for firefighters even though my house has a very low risk of burning down? Why should I pay for a rehab clinic even though I'm not an addict? Because it makes society better off, that's why.
- niij 7y ago> Why should I subsidize someone else's electric car? You shouldn't have to, that's absurd! They can buy their own car :) > Why should I pay for firefighters even though my house has a very low risk of burning down? To protect the life and property of the entire community. This gets down to the point of being a necessity to protect a large group of people vs an individuals choices affecting _only_ themselves. > Why should I pay for a rehab clinic even though I'm not an addict? Debatable whether you should have to pay for this or not. But I would prioritize someone's life when it's on the line over a nicety like a college education. You can survive without a college education, just like you can survive without a subsidized Tesla.
- commandlinefan 7y agoWell, if we're being shitty to each other... my tax burden is the thing that's hurting me the most - and you want to increase it (a lot) for your benefit. You can pay off your student loans, like we did. We can never pay off our taxes. Even if by some miracle Bernie doesn't confiscate my 401(k) savings and redistribute it to "the needy" and I can someday retire, I'll still be paying higher and higher taxes for somebody else to go to college... at least until the whole system collapses.
- donaldknuth123 7y agoHonestly the misinformation and fear mongering in this comment is staggering. Ignoring your blatantly antisocial comments about taxes and social improvement, nowhere has Bernie or any other Democrat for that matter suggested confiscating 401Ks. The free college plan and debt forgiveness will be paid for with Taxes on Wall Street trades. So unless you are a Wall Street banker you are unlikely to feel much impact and if you are then I have no sympathy for you, you've had decades of staggering growth at the expense of the rest of the country and your comeuppance is now due.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- refurb 7y agoI had it bad so everyone else should, too It's not that at all. It's "I didn't live high on the hog in college, so why should I pay you to?"
- firstplacelast 7y agoDid you demand money when they bailed out the banks? Or what about when they recently passed massive tax cuts for the rich? Did you demand money then? Do you demand money every time someone declares bankruptcy due to medical bills (they can't give that medical treatment back!). So many garbage people that can't see the forest for the trees. Think of how many more customers with disposable income you could have (if you wanted to start a business) if so many people in this country weren't deep in debt.
- basch 7y agothe bailouts were loans that were paid back with interest. the government profited off lending the banks money.
- firstplacelast 7y agoAnd what was the interest rate charged? Bet it was lower than what the government charges kids that are trying to make a better life for themselves and contribute to a productive society. Human garbage.
- basch 7y agoI wont try to interpret this accurately without help BUT it looks like the government profited 100B on 600B in loans? https://projects.propublica.org/bailout/ https://projects.propublica.org/bailout/ 16%? its also important to remember that a bunch of banks were forced to take bailouts against their own wishes, as either a precautionary measure, or possibly as marketing spin to make it look like everyone was in equal trouble. https://projects.propublica.org/bailout/main/list/stress_test https://projects.propublica.org/bailout/main/list/stress_tes... Some banks literally didnt have a choice, the government said "you are taking this money."
- Macross8299 7y agoCalling people "human garbage" and throwing an tantrum does not magically make scarcity disappear.
- commandlinefan 7y ago... or those of us who paid ours off years ago?