5 ms·
I'll start with one messed up point in this article: One way to get around this is to assume that we overeat by this trivial amount for a few years on end and t
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
I'll start with one messed up point in this article: One way to get around this is to assume that we overeat by this trivial amount for a few years on end and then we realize we’ve put on five or ten pounds...and then we decide to undereat every day for however long it takes to make up for it...But then how do animals do it?
Easy: most animals have weight which fluctuates significantly depending on food availability. In the wild, many are undernourished. Overeating is a real problem for domesticated animals. http://www.petobesityprevention.com/pet-obesity-fact-risks/ http://www.petobesityprevention.com/pet-obesity-fact-risks/
But now I'll argue against his real thesis. Based on other articles on this same topic, I get the impression Gary Taubes is an opponent of the "personal irresponsibility" theory of obesity - see this article for instance: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/28/health/28zuger.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=taubes&st=cse http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/28/health/28zuger.html?_r=1&#...
But unfortunately, he proposes to replace it with a much higher entropy theory. Rather than having one intuitive factor (personal irresponsibility) which explains several highly correlated outputs (obesity, low income, low education), he wants to propose a more complicated theory which explains only one of these outputs. Occams Razor suggests he is probably wrong, and from what I've seen, he doesn't even try to address this.
- shadowfox 16y agoJust to make sure I understood this correctly. Is your suggestion that low education, low income, obesity are all explained by personal irresponsibility?
- tbrownaw 16y ago> Rather than having one intuitive factor (personal irresponsibility) which explains several highly correlated outputs (obesity, low income, low education), he wants to propose a more complicated theory which explains only one of these outputs. I could go pick a bunch of correlated things and ascribe them all to "magic" or "Zeus" or what-have-you, but stuffing all the entropy into a black box like this shouldn't make it count as a "low-entropy theory".
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIt is low entropy relative to a theory which explains only one of several correlated things.
- gruseom 16y agoRather than having one intuitive factor (personal irresponsibility) which explains several highly correlated outputs (obesity, low income, low education) "Intuitive" seems like a weasel-word there. How do you define "personal irresponsibility"? How do you measure it? It's practically a mystical concept in comparison to the well-defined, measurable factors that Taubes is concerned with. That Taubes meticulously restricts himself to subjects that he's studied in depth (in this case, obesity and the associated literature) is a sign of intellectual honesty. I admire his refusal to go off on ideological tangents.
- barry-cotter 16y agoHow do you define "personal irresponsibility"? How do you measure it? You don't define personal irresponsibility, you change the word to one with less emotional baggage, that means something extremely close, that's easily measured. High discount rate.