3 ms·
The bottom of the page is a little weird. "Byzantine" is not Russian Liturgical Music. This is Byzantine Chant: https://youtu.be/Bs--5yMg1g0 https://youtu.be/
by rpmisms 7y ago
The bottom of the page is a little weird.
"Byzantine" is not Russian Liturgical Music.
This is Byzantine Chant: https://youtu.be/Bs--5yMg1g0 https://youtu.be/Bs--5yMg1g0
Also, Georgian Polyphony did not involve strings as a general rule. There were regional exceptions, but early Slavic polyphony was generally a capella.
Here's a good example of Gerogian polyphony: https://v-s.mobi/elia-lrdei-princeton-georgian-choirs-fall-2011-02:19 https://v-s.mobi/elia-lrdei-princeton-georgian-choirs-fall-2...
Sorry to nitpick, but I hate to see a fascinating corner of music ignored. Happy Listening!
- p1esk 7y agoIt seems like "Byzantine" is just an unfortunate label, which should be "church music", but if you expand it you will see that byzantine chant is present.
- rpmisms 7y agoIt's still too broad. Byzantine chant is an entire discipline in itself, and so are a bunch of other categories included in "Church Music". There's a category for Anglican choirs, so why not for Russian "Greek" chant or Kievan/Znamenny Polyphony? There's a lot of territory here.
- p1esk 7y agoIt's a map of Spotify, not an encyclopedia of music. I believe it's intended to give you a taste of something you've never heard of.
- rpmisms 7y agoThen I'll back up to the fact that it should actually play the correct music for the tag.
- gooseserbus 7y agoBlame Spotify's misclassification then
- crispyambulance 7y agoThe way this concept would really work, in practice, at a streaming service is as the basis for some kind of cluster analysis that could predict what you might want based on your listening behavior and that of others "like you". Having people use words to precisely pin-down entire genre's is perhaps near the end of it's usefulness.
- pwinnski 7y agoSpotify, and other commercial online sources, have long failed to get genres like "classical" right. It sounds like they're screwing up "Byzantine" as well, which is sadly unsurprising.
- aidenn0 7y agoWell it classifies Three Dog Night and Grand Funk Railroad as "Southern Rock" so it is certainly not perfect for other genre's either.
- crispyambulance 7y agoI've noticed miscategorizations in other genres as well. But It's OK. I think the interesting thing is how the musical snippets are different from each other rather than whether or not they're correct in an absolute sense. It's a step in the right direction, I think. And it's not surprising that the categorizations and recommendations you get on music streaming services like spotify aren't as ridiculously off the mark as they used to be.
- genreaday 7y agoFixed Byzantine. Will look into Georgian Polyphony later. Thanks for the feedback, and indeed, happy listening! https://twitter.com/GenreADay/status/1110510786277982208?s=20 https://twitter.com/GenreADay/status/1110510786277982208?s=2...
- rpmisms 7y agoSweet! Thanks for the answer and accuracy!