3 ms·
You know, I am starting to think more and more that copyright should ALLOW peer-to-peer sharing but not republishing. That's where the line should be drawn. The
by EGreg 16y ago
You know, I am starting to think more and more that copyright should ALLOW peer-to-peer sharing but not republishing. That's where the line should be drawn. There should be a clear definition of publishing, e.g. serving content upon request to anyone immediately on demand. That way, if the authorities can download something copyrighted from a public source which is not the original author, they can go prosecute that source. Just a thought. Ideas?
- steveklabnik 16y agoIt's just easier to eliminate intellectual property all together.
- philwelch 16y agoIt's actually not easier to eliminate intellectual property altogether. IP laws haven't been enforceable for years, but so far that's resulted in revenues declining across certain industries rather than going away completely. Think of all the change in the past 15 years the entertainment industry has faced and imagine how much bigger in magnitude--and how utterly sudden and catastrophic--immediate IP repeal would end up being.
- steveklabnik 16y agoThey deserve it. This is capitalism: evolve or die. I won't shed a tear. New media will make it work anyway. IP is not needed for content producers to survive and even thrive.
- philwelch 16y agoI'm not saying whether it's a good or bad idea, I'm saying whether it's easy or not. There's a difference between "creative destruction which will end up good in the long run" and "easy"--in fact, they're nearly exact opposites. Just look at the fallout from this last recession for an example. (On a side note, capitalism is defined by the legal enforcement of property rights. Abolishing intellectual property is probably the exact opposite of capitalism. The word you're looking for is "market".)
- steveklabnik 16y agoAh, this is a longer discussion than I'd like to have at the moment, but you're still assuming that IP is actually 'property.' It's not, at least in my mind. You're still right though: market would be a better fit. Markets and capitalism are pretty much interchangeable in my mind, which is why I made the slip.
- philwelch 16y agoProperty rights, as far as capitalism is concerned, are an artifact of law, not some fundamental philosophical truth. For capitalism to exist in a given domain, the government has to enforce property rights in that domain. That includes everything from cap-and-trade (where there are property rights to air emissions), water rights, real estate, equity in businesses, and yes, even copyrights and patents. Whether any of this actually constitutes "property" in a philosophical sense is an especially worthless genre of philosophical argument.
- EGreg 16y agoreally, so you would be totally OK if someone copied your article and slapped their name on it, or took your fictional characters and wrote some stories where they are made to be the scum of the earth?
- steveklabnik 16y agoYes.
- EGreg 16y agotoo bad it's not the case for many other people :)