3 ms·
> Me: So we can't really do anything? > Cop: Yep sorry So let's add a face recognition database. Now, two possibilities. One is they've got the DMV database
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> Me: So we can't really do anything?
> Cop: Yep sorry
So let's add a face recognition database. Now, two possibilities.
One is they've got the DMV database or some other mass database with photos of millions of people. They run your video through and it comes back with 117 matches. They all look like your guy, because that's what facial recognition is, so which one is it? Still no way to tell. And that's assuming the perpetrator was actually in the database.
The other possibility is that they're only using something like mugshot photos. Now it's only thousands of people in the database, so they only get one match. Hurray, we've caught him! Except that it could still have been any of the other 116 people who weren't in the smaller database. Or any of thousands of people from out of state or other countries who aren't even in the bigger database. So now we're going to go convict this guy because he's the only suspect and we've got a video of somebody who looks like him, even though he probably wasn't even the perpetrator.
Notice that this is only a problem for justice systems that want to be justice systems. If all you want is a pound of flesh from some random schmoe to demonstrate that you're catching bad guys even though you're not, it works great. Same if you're an authoritarian dictatorship, because then you can murder all 117 matches and to heck with all this hard work of making sure we found the right person. Which is why mass surveillance does more harm than good.
- toss1 7y agoOr, more properly, they use the 117 matches as a starting point in an investigation to eliminate most of them, i.e., they weren't in the area at the time, and identify the others who were in the area at the time. Probably not worth it for a petty crime, but for something more serious... Or, they just store the info, and when the same petty criminal pops up again with a similar crime, as is often the case, also track the particulars of this one to see if they get a match and add that to the prosecution list. Kind of like cell phone tracking. There's hundreds of phones in the vicinity of any one bank robbery, but when you get one that is in the vicinity of all three, probably a good idea to investigate the owner of that one...
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>Or, more properly, they use the 117 matches as a starting point in an investigation to eliminate most of them, i Maybe if you're a local politician, a cop or rich enough for them to know who you are you'll get that kind of service. For everyone else they'll just do nothing or nearly nothing and go back to playing with that APC they don't need. If they find your car as part of some other crime they'll add another page to the book they're throwing but you don't need a database to do that.
- toss1 7y agoExactly! For most minor crimes like car break in, unless it's part of a string, they'll be unlikely to assign resources to the investigation (unless the victim is a VIP), but for a more serious crime, there's some good clues for the investigation.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Or, more properly, they use the 117 matches as a starting point in an investigation to eliminate most of them, i.e., they weren't in the area at the time, and identify the others who were in the area at the time. Which is how you get false convictions, because you're starting with a list of essentially random people, with no guarantee that the true perpetrator is even on it. Then you ping cell phone records, and the actual perpetrator left their phone at home because they knew they'd be committing a crime, but one person out of a hundred on your list of random people happened to be in the area at that time, and that combined with what looks like their face on video is enough to convince a jury. Or convince the accused that a jury would be convinced so they'll plead guilty to a crime they didn't commit. > Or, they just store the info, and when the same petty criminal pops up again with a similar crime, as is often the case, also track the particulars of this one to see if they get a match and add that to the prosecution list. So you get another video with the same face matching the same hundred odd people, which increases the chances that one of the other random people on the list was in the vicinity of at least one of the crimes while the actual perpetrator always leaves their phone at home, and now the innocent party gets convicted of multiple counts. > Kind of like cell phone tracking. There's hundreds of phones in the vicinity of any one bank robbery, but when you get one that is in the vicinity of all three, probably a good idea to investigate the owner of that one... Then it turns out to be the alarm tech or insurance adjuster or regional bank manager responding to the robbery, or some company that always makes deposits on Friday around 3PM which is also when the robbery crew always robs the banks. Which makes it a lot easier to choose any of those parties as a scapegoat if you can't find who really did it. Computers are really good at finding random coincidences in large data sets. Humans are really bad at not interpreting that kind of noise as signal.