17 ms·
“Probably 95 percent of the people that are charged with something are guilty of something,” she asserted. “They may not be guilty of what they’re exactly charg
by chrisco255 7y ago
“Probably 95 percent of the people that are charged with something are guilty of something,” she asserted. “They may not be guilty of what they’re exactly charged with, but they may be guilty of a lesser offense, okay? … And you have probably 90 percent of those people who are looking for the best deal possible.”
What a disturbing quote and very telling about the state of our justice system.
- tyingq 7y agoAlso notable: "Since 2014, for example, she has only visited one client in jail, according to court receipts." So any strategy discussion is minutes before copping a plea, etc. I'd call it a plea mill. Ugh.
- noonespecial 7y agoEven more chilling considering that thanks to the state of the law today we are all guilty of some "lesser offense" right now. It would be interesting to calculate the "default jail sentence" of the average citizen if an overzealous prosecutor decided to randomly harass them.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y agoThis is a somewhat common sentiment, probably because it's cynical enough to conform with people's prior conceptions. But I doubt it is actually true. Consider, for example, the various congressional investigations of Hilary Clinton in 2014/2015. If everybody was guilty of some crime(s) punishable by jail time, it would follow that some of those overly brought criminal statues would have come up in those proceedings, considering there were any number of high-powered lawyers tasked with finding anything against her that would stick. (The Clinton example may be imperfect because of partisanship, but I can't currently think of any other widely-known case where prosecutors were trying to "throw the book" at someone. I'm specifically not focussing on the main issues of those investigations, because those could never apply to the average person, so resist the urge to argue e-mail servers.)
- mehrdadn 7y agoJaywalking appears to be a crime (misdemeanor) in some jurisdictions. If you pick someone from those jurisdictions... chances are good that they've jaywalked at some point. Doesn't mean a Congress investigating you would ever find evidence on it, or that it would care even if it did, but it does make it more likely that the statement that everyone commits a crime is true. Right?
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y agoQuote: "some crime(s) punishable by jail time" The charge is that the definition of serious crime has expanded to make everyone liable to go to jail. Traffic infractions do not fit the charge, because while a large majority of people will at some point break those laws, very few people consider the rules of the road an oppressive plot to enslave the population.
- rhino369 7y agoNot to get too political, but the FBI actually revised their memo clearing her because they accidentally used language which would have established she met all the elements of a crime. I.e. they used the words "grossly negligent" but changed them to "extremely careless." So I'm sure you can say they were trying to make anything stick.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- reallydude 7y agoCareless or not, you would be charged as a military serviceman. The double-standards are obvious, but the wordplay makes good news fodder. https://fas.org/irp/doddir/army/ar380-5/vi.htm https://fas.org/irp/doddir/army/ar380-5/vi.htm How the FBI classifies something, is wholly irrelevant.
- thephyber 7y agoI agree with gp's sentiment, but I think police and prosecutors don't currently have enough resources to prosecute every infraction. I fear, however, that this is largely a function of technological advancement. China is already charging drivers for their traffic infractions by withdrawing the fine from their digital (WeChat?) wallets before they finish their commute. I doubt there's a lawyer alive that has read all of the statutes that govern me in the jurisdictions I'm currently in (and all of the applicable caselaw that defines the jurisprudence and interpretation of those statutes). You seem to be arguing the ability and likelihood of a guilty plea/verdict against someone winning in court (and the risk of the prosecutor's reputation for spending). That's a high burden compared to simply being objectively guilty (from a "God's eye view"). The difference is the gray area of interpretation, the burden of proof (especially when it comes to motives and state-of-mind).
- travisjungroth 7y agoIn a three strikes state, the author of Three Felonies a Day would argue the default jail sentence is life. https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748704471504574438900830760842 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748704471504574438...
- anywherenotes 7y agoThere's a podcast, by the name: 'Serial', in season two they go into regular courtrooms with non-fancy cases - fights, etc. In one episode after the defendant has been found not guilty, the judge presiding over the case berated them for not accepting a plea deal, and wasting the court time. This is after the person has been found not guilty.
- akulkarni7 7y agoseason three
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- AlexCoventry 7y agoGot a more specific reference? I'd like to hear that.
- dv_dt 7y agohttps://serialpodcast.org/ https://serialpodcast.org/
- AlexCoventry 7y agoI meant more specific within the series, like a timestamp.
- theIV 7y agohttps://serialpodcast.org/season-three/2/youve-got-some-gauls https://serialpodcast.org/season-three/2/youve-got-some-gaul... Probably about halfway through the episode, maybe a little further.
- AlexCoventry 7y agoThanks.
- ProCicero 7y agoWhen you work with the assumption that police usually only arrest a person when they have strong evidence that person actually committed the crime, it's not that surprising. Whether that is a good working assumption to begin with is another debate.
- tyingq 7y agoMost people unwittingly commit lots of crimes.
- dv_dt 7y agoIt's a poor assumption that violates due process and presumption of innocence. Applying the assumption makes our current justice system act in the manner that is similar to some of the original complaints of American revolutionaries about British colonial rule.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI think there are two distinct questions that you are co-mingling. The first is, do police only arrest (and prosecutors charge) people when they have strong evidence that they committed the crime? I think the answer is, "Yes, most of the time, in many districts" - but not all of the time, and not in all districts. The second question is, "Should the court system act like the police only arrest guilty people"? And the answer is, absolutely not. From your answer, I guess that you only cared about the second question. But the first question is the one raised by ProCicero, and is also an important question.
- dv_dt 7y agoNo the question of due process applies to who, how, and when the police decide to arrest people too. They should be expected to strongly apply due process and the presumption of innocence too. It's too easy to give police and prosecutors a pass on misbehavior if we characterize their primary responsibilities as focused on catching the criminals.
- jandrese 7y ago
- radcon 7y agoThis is why selective / arbitrary enforcement of the law is dangerous -- everyone breaks some kind of law every day. If the government gets to choose when (or if) the law is applied, then it's no different from tyranny. There are so many laws that even Congress can't keep track of just the federal ones[1]. Then there are state laws, local laws, regulations from organizations like the FAA or motor vehicle departments, etc. [1] https://blogs.loc.gov/law/2013/03/frequent-reference-question-how-many-federal-laws-are-there/ https://blogs.loc.gov/law/2013/03/frequent-reference-questio...
- Natsu 7y ago> “Probably 95 percent of the people that are charged with something are guilty of something,” she asserted. “They may not be guilty of what they’re exactly charged with, but they may be guilty of a lesser offense, okay? … And you have probably 90 percent of those people who are looking for the best deal possible.” > What a disturbing quote and very telling about the state of our justice system. Yeah, why are we charging so many innocent people with crimes? 1 in 20 seems a bit high. Ideally, cases with weak evidence wouldn't go to trial.
- maxheadroom 7y ago>Yeah, why are we charging so many innocent people with crimes? Votes. Prosecutors/Judges/etc. (depending on jurisdictions in the states) in the states are all about votes based on "being tough on crime". They depend on the police to get the people into the system and they take care of the rest. The staggering amount of people being found innocent[0,1,2] is very telling about how the core righteous retribution drive of the system is damaging: It doesn't really matter who gets served on a platter for 'x' as much as it is that at least that someone is served on a platter. Seemingly, they would rather put an innocent person up than to not have anyone served-up for judgment for a crime. [0] - "*...a conservative estimate is that 1 percent of the US prison population, approximately 20,000 people, is falsely convicted." https://archive.fo/mKriP https://archive.fo/mKriP [1] - https://archive.fo/ImQPL https://archive.fo/ImQPL [2] - https://archive.fo/wqBm3 https://archive.fo/wqBm3
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]