3 ms·
> your personal position has no weight in the decision-making process, you have no say in the matter. Not on an individual level, no, but collectively it could
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
> your personal position has no weight in the decision-making process, you have no say in the matter.
Not on an individual level, no, but collectively it could. I'm not advocating that webdevs organize to boycott companies bloating things because it isn't really that big a deal, but if we imagine the ethical situation were much more important then that's how they could go about changing the situation.
Of course, it's much easier to pretend that they have no option at all than to admit that, compared to being slightly less well off, it really isn't that big a deal to them. It lets them virtue-signal that they care without accepting any blame for the situation, while also conveniently allowing them to point the finger at their mortal enemies in marketing. Nevermind that marketing needs to put food on the table too.
- luckylion 7y agoThat's generalized to the point of uselessness, isn't it? "You're contributing to imperialist wars" - "No, I'm not" - "well, not personally, but if everybody on earth stood together and said no, nobody would be going to war". You're very right that marketing needs to put food on the table too, that's what I hinted at regarding being forced. There's a very clear difference though, in deciding what to do (marketing) and not deciding what to do (devs, at least those where they aren't involved in the decision, which is a lot). Whoever is in charge could very much make a different choice in this particular manner, a developer getting a task cannot. What a marketing person can't do, similarly, is say that they won't do their job. How they do their job is mostly up to them, just as the developer tends to be free in choosing how they get that 3rd-party-lib into the site, as long as they do it.