4 ms·
The Mac Mini is sort of limited by the lack of any graphics horsepower and the lack of stand-alone displays from Apple. You also can't get one with a really pow
by mort96 7y ago
The Mac Mini is sort of limited by the lack of any graphics horsepower and the lack of stand-alone displays from Apple. You also can't get one with a really powerful CPU.
It's a cool machine, but the tiny form factor is fairly limiting.
- saagarjha 7y agoThere’s the Pro Display XDR, but it’s obviously quite expensive.
- mort96 7y agoYeah, I'd expect nobody to buy a $6000 display+stand for their $1000 machine, except for special circumstances where a movie studio or something needs a reference monitor and just a weak machine to just show images on it. That's not exactly the mainstream desktop use case.
- tracker1 7y agoIIRC, it's relatively cheap as a reference monitor for the price. Way more than I'd want to pay, but compared to some of the studio alternatives.
- mort96 7y agoIt is. I'm not saying it's a bad or overpriced monitor. I'm saying it absolutely doesn't fit the common somewhat budget-conscious desktop use case.
- askafriend 7y agoMac Mini supports Thunderbolt 3 which has enough throughput to run a powerful external GPU with minimal (~10%) efficiency loss.
- KibbutzDalia 7y agoHa!
- mort96 7y agoThat's fair. From what I hear, thunderbolt GPUs are a fair bit more finicky than internal PCIe ones, so for a desktop I'd still say having an internal GPU is better, but it should at least be a reasonably good workaround. It's a bit sad to trade reliability, GPU performance, tidiness (since the external enclosure adds more boxes and wires and power supplies), price, and CPU power just for a smaller core computer though. It gets even worse when you want a couple of big HDDs which would have just gone in drive bays with a traditional computer. With the mac mini, you'd have to add even more expensive external enclosures to your desk, which is expensive and messy. Suddenly, instead of a nice self-contained smallish desktop, you have an impressively small core machine box, with a wire to your GPU box (which has to be on top of the desk due to the short length of thunderbolt cables), a wire to your HDD box, and you still have the slower CPU. I don't really mean to say the Mac mini is a poor choice, it probably fits a bunch of desktop use cases reasonably well. It's just not as optimal as it could be. To illustrate how a real small and powerful desktop from Apple could've been: I'm using a really small (though not as small as the mac mini) Fractal Design Node 304 [0], with a 2.5 slot width, full length GPU, a 3.5" drive, two 2.5" drives, an m.2, and a standard ITX card with regular RAM and CPU slots. I have a 1080Ti and an i7 6700k in it with no thermal issues. Apple could've made a similarly expandable machine in a smaller form factor with better thermals and looks, but they... don't. [0]: https://www.fractal-design.com/home/product/cases/node-series/node-304-black https://www.fractal-design.com/home/product/cases/node-serie...
- bradknowles 7y agoIf Apple could do it, then so can other companies. So, where are the other companies that manufacture the Not-Apple Super Mac Mini that you’re talking about? EDIT: More importantly, where are the other companies that are selling billions of dollars worth of this kind of hardware?
- mort96 7y ago
- mort96 7y agoI'm actually really curious, can someone please tell me why pointing out that the mac mini makes certain trade-offs for its form factor is apparently controversial?