6 ms·
I'm aware this is legally the case, but I think this is yet another sign that default opt-in isn't a legitimate agreement, society has become pretty litigious a
by munk-a 7y ago
I'm aware this is legally the case, but I think this is yet another sign that default opt-in isn't a legitimate agreement, society has become pretty litigious and I think some of the understanding around default opt-ins during enrollment for other services and third party data sales need to be revisited.
I find them to be highly unethical and to generally result in a contract negotiated without compensation and any communication in good faith.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> society has become pretty litigious and I think some of the understanding around default opt-ins during enrollment for other services and third party data sales need to be revisited Are you saying these two ideas are related? If so, I don't quite see the connection -- can you expand a bit?
- xvector 7y agoCredit reporting companies should burn.
- iratewizard 7y agoNot that poster, but I believe what they're saying is that because we heavily use the law to structure society, it's time to use the law to remove an undesired aspect: default opt-ins.
- djsumdog 7y agoThere is certainly no meeting-of-the-minds when it comes to EULAs, car loan applications and other such contracts.
- g051051 7y agoThis is not "default opt-in", like having the "Subscribe to our email newsletter" checked on an online order form. The sharing of credit worthiness information is the cornerstone of your ability to get credit. It's not a hidden extra, it's not something you can choose not to get, there's no "opt out". It's a condition of doing business with the credit grantor. It's like opting out of having a driver's license. If you want to drive, you have to have one.
- mattmanser 7y agoIt's a recent thing, in the last 30/40 years and I also thought that I read it's efficacy was quite questionable, but could be wrong.
- amluto 7y ago> The sharing of credit worthiness information is the cornerstone of your ability to get credit. It's not a hidden extra, it's not something you can choose not to get, there's no "opt out". It's a condition of doing business with the credit grantor. No, this is only true because the law does not meaningfully restrict abusive contracts. Sure, a credit card issuer should [0] be able to ask some agency for information on your credit risk. It does not follow at all that the issuer should have permission to give information back to the agency. [0] Even this is debatable. One might reasonably argue that the use of inscrutable conditions for the issuance of credit cards is discriminatory and should, as a matter of public policy, be disallowed. As a simple example of how this could work, all credit card issuers could be required to instead issue prepaid cards with identical terms, benefits, and usage from a merchant’s perspective, and credit could be an opt-in extra feature.
- g051051 7y ago> It does not follow at all that the issuer should have permission to give information back to the agency. The agreements you sign when requesting and getting credit explicitly grant that right.
- pmiller2 7y agoNothing is really “explicit” when it’s buried in pages of small print legalese. If everyone just read (forget understood, just read) everything they ever signed or agreed to thoroughly, life would slow down significantly.
- innocenat 7y agoMany CC contracts I have signed (not US or EU banks) have explicit section and additional (mandatory) signature specifically for sharing data with credit reporting company.