3 ms·
There is also the matter of population density. Compare the population density of the UK or Germany to China, then to the US. If you have fewer passengers per
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
There is also the matter of population density. Compare the population density of the UK or Germany to China, then to the US.
If you have fewer passengers per square mile then you either need smaller vehicles or less frequent operation to fill larger ones. People naturally prefer the first option.
But the country isn't a city. It would be possible for an individual US city to have the population density required to support more effective mass transit (at least to the extent that it exists in Europe or Asia). NYC is the highest density major city in the US and largely manages to do that.
To make it work elsewhere would require the same sort of densities as New York, which would require allowing people to build more high density housing there.
- sokoloff 7y agoIt would require both allowing and people pervasively desiring Manhattan level of density of housing. I think that might be workable in San Francisco (with the desire being there). I'm not sure that level of density is desired anywhere else (as measured by people buying land and building such buildings).
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThere are a few other cities that might manage it in the US. Seattle, Boston, maybe D.C. Certainly not anything like Kansas City or Tucson, because you have to have enough density pressure around the city to actually require tall buildings. If you can satisfy all the local housing demand with single family homes and still have plenty of empty land within reasonable distance of the city center, there isn't enough reason to compress it into a smaller area just to have taller buildings and put things a little closer together. But those cities also don't have anything near the same traffic problems either. Where you're really screwed is in places like Los Angeles and Houston, where you have large populations but also so much sprawl and undeveloped land that taller buildings aren't really justified. So they end up in this unhappy medium with enough population density to have bad traffic but not enough to have good mass transit, and weak demand for higher density housing. But that still doesn't justify the zoning restrictions that exist in a lot of these places. Houston largely doesn't have them while Los Angeles does, and you can check for yourself the difference in rent. Even if without them Los Angeles still wouldn't be New York, because it would at least be better than it is.
- sokoloff 7y agoLos Angeles is significantly more dense than Houston, despite the cited zoning restrictions in LA. Maywood is 23K/mi^2 with several other LA incorporated areas in the 15-20K/mi^2 density. Houston is under 10K/mi^2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_by_population_density https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b...
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThis is partially my fault for comparing LA with a city, but what most people think of as "Los Angeles" is really the LA metro area or LA county, so the better comparison would be LA county with Harris county (where Houston is).
- sokoloff 7y agoThat's fair and, being an east coaster, I don't have a good feel for what is/isn't "LA". I wasn't trying to nit-pick or strawman. Even with that, it seems like zoning isn't what's kept LA rents high. LA has parts that are fairly dense and more free zoning doesn't seem to have made Houston become notably dense.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> LA has parts that are fairly dense and more free zoning doesn't seem to have made Houston become notably dense. That's kind of the point. Less restrictive zoning isn't going to make areas like that a lot more dense, because they're huge areas with open spaces and people aren't going to build skyscrapers surrounded by empty lots even if they're allowed to. The problem LA has is that they have some areas zoned for density, but not enough of them. So you get a section full of skyscrapers and correspondingly a lot of demand for housing near there, but then zoning that requires low density housing in nearby sections, which keeps rents high because that low density housing would otherwise have been replaced by medium density housing. Whereas with Houston you have some high density areas, but with less zoning the density falls off more organically and it's more of a medium density everywhere than high density in one place and low density right next to it. Which isn't much better for traffic when the average density comes out the same, but it's a lot better for rents, because it makes for a lot less scarcity in the market for land where medium and high density housing can be built.