3 ms·
It seemed likely to me that Japan and in particular MITI couldn't continue on as they had been but I was an outlier and so thought I was probably wrong. Don't
by gumby 7y ago
It seemed likely to me that Japan and in particular MITI couldn't continue on as they had been but I was an outlier and so thought I was probably wrong. Don't forget the US was just emerging from the stagflation of the 70s and while they have addressed that one macroeconomic phenomenon haven't made any progress on any of the things that lead to it.
So having said that, 5Gen was a "moonshot" from a bunch of bureaucrats who could see the writing on the wall, but mistakenly let it get hyped. Compare that to ARPA who used to place a whole bunch of batshit crazy bets that were clearly nonsensical though being done by legitimately smart people: that gave us the Internet, among other things. They also funded infrastructure to get there (e.g. MOSIS).
Since then (the now named) DARPA and corporate labs have lost interest in much blue sky work. "I don't agree that "when industry takes over science, we lose the science." Corp research gave us the transistor, semiconductor, SEM, WIMP interface etc. It could again. Pharma is one of the few fields where fundamental research is still done.
(I wouldn't say regulatory approval has had much of any influence in the cost or output of pharma research BTW; getting meaningful results is hard and if you want drugs that are better than the standard of care you need to do that work. I do think the regulatory framework around marketing and reimbursement has had a much larger impact on which API candidates get advanced into programs.
I'm biased in what I consider fundamental; I'd agree with you on TCP/IP, mpus, RISC, the Mac, generational GC (another corp research result BTW) and fab. (WDM is another corp invention about 100 years old). Some of the others I consider less fundamental or less influential (Cedar? CLU was far more influential even if no real programs were written in it).
The fact is research is hard, and skills in basic research and the skills of translational research are rarely present in the same person.
- kragen 7y agoThank you very much! Do you think the ARPA approach is better, or better for certain cases? The accounts I've read of the invention of WIMP and transistors resemble “bunch of batshit bets by smart people”, if I have the story right, but I don't know anything about the SEM and semiconductors. (Weren't semiconductors Bose in the 1890s?) A lot of my list clearly was pretty applied; I didn't mean to suggest they were all basic. Cedar in particular I mentioned because it inspired Oberon, Java (né Oak), in some sense Xi (and ropes in lots of other systems), and maybe sam and the plumber, though maybe that was convergent Blit evolution. But certainly that impact is small compared to the LSP. (Were Smalltalk iterator methods convergent evolution or were they taken from CLU?) I'm very surprised at your view on pharma. Sounds like my opinions need to change.
- gumby 7y agoWell, life is a huge parallel process that requires a diversity of inputs, so you need blue sky, "stupid" stuff, boring spadework and directed development, all at once. (and those definitions change; as fields go through their "stamp collecting" modes, as taxonomy/biology did in the 18th and 19th centuries, that was exciting. High energy physics is stuck there at the moment, again). So yes, we do need someone like the ARPA of old. Licklider, Bob Taylor, and the like are heroes in my opinion and I don't really see their like today.